Changes to medicinal cannabis rules will make little difference, says NORML
The changes announced by the Government today will do little to improve safe legal access for patients using cannabis
medicinally, says cannabis advocacy group NORML.
An estimated one-in-twenty New Zealanders use cannabis medicinally. Approximately 150 patients have been approved to use
Satixex®, while three other patients have been approved to use other “non pharmaceutical cannabis products” (Elixinol,
Aseco and Tilray, respectively).
Sativex® remains the only approved cannabis product.
The only change announced by Associate Health Minister Peter Dunne is delegating his special authority to approve
applications to the Ministry of Health.
“Peter Dunne says he did nothing more than rubber stamp applications – taking ‘a few minutes'”, noted Chris Fowlie,
spokesperson for NORML NZ Inc (the National Organisation for the Reform of Marijuana Laws). “Yet this is the only change
he is making. So applications that now take an average of six months will, according to Peter Dunne, save a few
“Dunne also claims to have approved every application put before him, but officials only present him with applications
that they have already approved themselves – and that they know he will approve. Today’s changes will not alter that,”
said Chris Fowlie. “Officials will continue to over-rule doctors and specialists. They just won’t need to take a few
minutes to get Dunne to sign applications they deem successful.”
There have been at least twenty applications for Sativex® declined by Ministry of Health officials. These applications
were apparently never put before Dunne. Likewise, Helen Kelly’s application was not technically rejected, but was
strongly encouraged to be withdrawn.
The policy change announced today fails to resolve any of the major issues facing patients:
1. The change only applies to “non-pharmaceutical medicinal cannabis products“.
2. Access to Sativex® remains difficult, and at $1200-$1400 per month is prohibitively expensive for most patients.
The policy change announced by the Government today will not change that.
3. While “non-pharmaceutical medicinal cannabis products” will no longer require Peter Dunne’s personal approval,
that won’t change the source of most of the delays and obstructions: the Ministry of Health.
4. Patients must still convince a specialist doctor to apply for special approval from the Ministry of Health.
5. The Ministry’s guidelines that must be met are unchanged – and these have proven to be the real problem. The
strict criteria (here or see below) are too difficult for most patients and doctors:
o Patients must have a severe or life-threatening condition;
o Provide evidence that conventional treatments have been tried but did not work;
o Provide evidence that the risk/ benefit of the cannabis product has been adequately considered by qualified
o Application is from a relevant specialist or the Chief Medical Officer of their District Health Board
o Peer review of the application eg Hospital Ethics Committee approval, Drug or Therapeutics Committee review, or
review by other specialists;
o Arranging a Certificate of Analysis from an accredited laboratory
6. Even after gaining approval, the specialist must then obtain an import permit to actually import the product,
liase with Customs in both countries, have the original of the import permit couriered to the supplier, arrange a
pharmacy in NZ to store and dispense it – a process that can cost around $3000 and take several months. For example the
Canadian product Tilray was promoted as “approved” in October 2015, yet that approval was only for one specific patient,
Dr Hunana Hickey, and she still does not have her medicine five months later.
7. The Ministry of Health continues to unlawfully treat cannabidiol (CBD) as a controlled drug requiring special
approval, forcing patients and advocates including NORML NZ Inc to proceed with a legal challenge lead by Sue Grey;
8. The Ministry of Health continues to claim no botanical cannabis products from the USA are legal – despite being
legal in 26 states;
9. The Ministry of Health continues to instruct NZ Customs to seize imports of cannabis medicines
“The change made today is a step in the right direction, but it is a very small step and it will remain extremely
difficult for patients to obtain safe legal access to medicinal cannabis,” said Mr Fowlie. “However it does prove the
rules can be changed whenever they want – and this could have been done any time.
“NORML advocates for broader changes that would benefit more people. For example they could change section 22 of the
1977 Misuse of Drugs Regulations, which prohibits doctors from prescribing cannabis (while allowing them to prescribe
cocaine and opioids), and is the root cause of all the unfair restrictions on medicinal cannabis. It could be easily
amended so that doctors could prescribe cannabis medications like any other medicine.”