Spencer vs Ministry of Health: Human Rights Commission welcomes decision on disabled New Zealanders and their caregivers
The Human Rights Commission has paid tribute to Margaret Spencer who has successfully challenged Government policies
that excluded family members from receiving publicly funded payments for providing disability support. Mrs Spencer has
provided care for her 48-year-old son Paul, who has Downs Syndrome, throughout his life.
“Margaret Spencer has always said that she was fighting not just for herself and her son but for many families in the
same situation, we are very grateful to New Zealanders like her who fight for human rights on all of our behalf,” said
Chief Human Rights Commissioner David Rutherford.
“Today’s landmark judgement is a testament to the efforts people with disabilities and their families have put in over
many years in battling a system that frequently fails to acknowledge and respect their rights.”
“We welcome the Court’s order that the Ministry of Health should educate its staff about the importance of the human
rights of disabled people and their caregivers. Public policies that uphold and promote human rights principles deliver
better outcomes for all New Zealanders.”
This afternoon, the High Court released its judgment on remedies in the case of Spencer v Attorney General. The Human
Rights Commission appeared as in intervener in the case. It is a landmark decision, and the first in which the Court has
awarded monetary damages to a claimant who has suffered loss as a result of a discriminatory Government policy.
It represents a new stage in the litigation arising from Atkinson v Ministry of Health, where the Courts ruled that the
pre-2013 Ministry of Health policy not to pay family caregivers for the care they provided their disabled adult children
constituted unlawful discrimination
ENDS