INDEPENDENT NEWS

MeNZB Debate: Unethical antiscience scaremongering

Published: Thu 16 Jun 2005 08:49 AM
The Meningococcal B Debate
Unethical anti-science scaremongering
A media statement issued this week by Ron Law and Barbara Sumner Burstyn claims that results of international trials on meningococcal B vaccines shows an increase in meningococcal risk in pre-schoolers.
(See… Increased Vaccine Risk in Pre-Schoolers - Explain )
This is a total misinterpretation of the international trials and the meaning of ‘confidence intervals’. There is absolutely no scientific validity in this press statement.
The studies referred to (discussed in Sexton K et al, NZ Med Journal, 20 Aug 2004) used a meningococcal vaccine two dose regime and showed that two doses were not effective with pre-schoolers. The importance of these references is to recognise that children, particularly younger children, need three doses; two doses will not be enough to offer protection.
The studies are presented with statistics using confidence intervals. A confidence interval is the range in which you expect a true result to lie within. A confidence interval that crosses zero is an indication of lack of efficacy, not an increased risk of disease.
This is another example of anti-science rhetoric from these misguided people. These authors have no scientific credibility and once again they have shown an inability to understand or read the basic statistics used to explain vaccine clinical trials. This is both highly unethical and unfair scaremongering for NZ parents and our children.
Dr Nikki Turner
Immunisation Advisory Centre
University of Auckland

Next in Lifestyle

Endeavour arrives at Tūranganui-a-Kiwa as part of Tuia 250
By: RNZ
NZ Improv Fest Turns It Up To Eleven
By: NZ Improv Festival
$12 million investment in stimulating content for tamariki
By: NZ On Air
Author Jack Lasenby remembered as master storyteller
By: RNZ
Tuia 250 Voyage flotilla launches with tribute
By: New Zealand Government
Whangaparāoa iwi commemorate arrival of waka tīpuna
By: New Zealand Government
Tuia 250 - Te Pōwhiri - Te Whanganui o Hei / Mercury Bay
By: Tuia 250
HMB Endeavour replica arrives in NZ to join Tuia 250 Voyage
By: Tuia 250
Tuia Mātauranga Roadshow kicks off
By: Ministry of Education
UK govt's expression of regret to Gisborne iwi
By: RNZ
Release of critical book on Cook Commemorations
By: Kia Mau
Endeavour was a military invasion
By: Auckland Peace Action
Extinction Rebellion Aotearoa launch decolonisation action
By: Extinction Rebellion
More laugh therapy ordered for New Zealanders
By: NZ On Air
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media