2 February 2012
Good League Tables Have Potential
“Ever since national standards were first suggested, there has been disagreement about how the information that is
collected should beused. The primary teachers’ union (NZEI), want the information kept private. But the new Minister of
Education, Hekia Parata, is saying that not only will the information be made public but that the Ministry of Education
may actually compile such ‘league tables.’ Minister Parata is right to consider this,” says Steve Thomas, Researcher at
Maxim Institute.
“The data has the potential to be very useful. Information about schools is a precious commodity and the reason it is so
highly sought is simple—people want to know what goes on in classrooms and how well children are learning at school.
This can help us understand which schools need the mostassistance, and can help parents make informed choices about
their children’s education. As long as the data is reported well and with sufficient detail,there is absolutely no need
for alarm,” says Thomas.
“It is better that the Ministry releases the data in a way that gives the most helpful and accurate indication about how
school’s are performing, rather than leaving others to crudely interpret the data or to speculate with inadequate
information,” says Thomas.
“Good reporting would mean, among other things, that the data is adjusted to account for pupils’ socio-economic
background, and that pupils’ progress, not just pupils’ raw test scores are reported.”
ENDS