New Zealanders Leave for Passchendaele Centenary
The centenary of one of the greatest tragedies of World War One will be commemorated by hundreds of New Zealanders and
Australians early this month (October).
One of New Zealand’s foremost war historians, Professor Glyn Harper, leaves this week to revisit Passchendaele where 846
Kiwi soldiers were killed in two hours in a futile attempt to take the Passchendaele ridge.
Glyn Harper, Professor of War Studies at Massey University, will spend two days on reconnaissance at the site and pay
his own tribute to the battle which was “the darkest day in New Zealand military history”, an attack that should never
have gone ahead.
In Paris on October 6 he’ll catch up with a party of New Zealanders who he’ll mentor and act as their expert historian
on their journey to the Passchendaele centenary on October 12.
Glyn Harper, who wrote the definitive book about the battle entitled Massacre At Passchendaele: The New Zealand Story, says the attack, ordered by overall commander, Field Marshal Haig, was New Zealand’s worst military disaster and should
never have happened.
Passchendaele was part of the Ypres campaign which lasted from July to November 1917 and, early in October, four Anzac
divisions succeeded in securing the foothills around the Passchendaele ridge and deserted village.
“It was a stunning success by the divisions, three Australian and one New Zealand, who attacked side by side. But, as
they took the foothills, the rain bucketed down and turned the whole area into a quagmire,” he said. “The divisions
should have stayed until conditions improved. The weather was atrocious and it was impossible to move the artillery
Instead Field Marshal Haig wanted to continue and ordered the New Zealand divisions to storm 3,000 yards and take the
Passchendaele ridge without adequate artillery support.
“It was an incredible distance in a quagmire and they were massacred. The ridge was well defended and the Germans knew
in advance because a British deserter told them the night before,” Glyn Harper says.
Within two hours 846 Kiwi soldiers were killed, 138 died of their wounds in the next few days and a further 2,000 were
wounded. The Australians suffered similar casualties.
Our troops, commanded by General Andrew Russell, led the charge. It was the first time a New Zealand division had failed
to take its objective. When the attack was called off that afternoon, it took three days to clear the battlefield.
Glyn Harper said our division was a spent force and they saw little action until they played a significant role in
winning the war in 1918.
“Their loss impacted on families throughout the country for decades to come. It shaped New Zealand as a nation,” he
Many lessons were learned from Passchendaele. “We learned that good quality soldiers were not a resource to be
squandered and it was a betrayal of their trust that they were given an order that was impossible to fulfil,” Glyn
“It led to the Freyberg Charter in the Second World War where our government gave New Zealand commanders the authority
to say no if they didn’t agree with given orders.”
So angry was Prime Minister William Massey, who was in England at the time, that he told British PM, Lloyd George, his
men “should not be shot down like rabbits” and there were serious consequences if it happened again.
The party, organised by Stephen Parsons House Of Travel, will spend 10 days in France and Belgium, and visit the site of
the Battle of the Somme, Waterloo, the towns of Ypres and Arras before attending Tyne Cot Cemetery in Belgium, the
largest Commonwealth War Grave cemetery, for the October 12 ceremony. At the cemetery the names of 1,179 missing New
Zealand soldiers are recorded.
Glyn Harper admits he will be moved to tears at the cemetery. “Our soldiers were so young and cut down in their prime.
It was just slaughter,” he says.
One particularly interesting visit the HOT party will make is to the extensive tunnels at Arras built by an independent
tunnelling unit comprising up to 500 miners from the West Coast, Buller and Waihi.
“They built a network of tunnels over a year which contained an underground hospital, railway, barracks, rooms, military
headquarters and dining rooms for about 20,000 troops,” he said. “In the tunnels, troops were moved forward to prepare
for the Battle of Arras and, when the attack started in April 1917, they broke through the surface close to the German
The tunnels have inspired Glyn Harper’s latest book, a children’s story about Bobby, the Littlest War Hero. Bobby, the canary, played an important role in alerting tunnellers about the level of toxic gases in the mine. It will
be launched next year.
While Passchendaele was a disaster, Glyn says New Zealand can be immensely proud of the role our forces played in 1917,
at Arras, Messines and the Battle of Broodseinde, where our division captured the foothills on October 4.
It was there 100 years ago that legendary All Black captain, Dave Gallaher, lost his life.