INDEPENDENT NEWS

Dolphin plan deeply flawed

Published: Mon 19 Aug 2019 12:20 PM
August 19, 2019
The government’s proposed Threat Management Plan (TMP) for Hector’s and Maui dolphin will put hundreds of small fishermen out of business and hundreds of millions of dollars will be lost from regional economies – and may not save one dolphin.
Not one Maui dolphin has been confirmed caught by a commercial fisherman since 2002 and, while recognising Maui are critically endangered, the TMP itself claims toxoplasmosis, a cat-borne disease that enters waterways, is the main threat to Maui. It also concedes that set netting may capture an estimated one dolphin every 10 years and in the trawl fishery one in 50 years.
The Hector’s dolphin meanwhile is numbered at around 15,700 and the science shows the numbers are increasing.
Seafood New Zealand chief executive, Tim Pankhurst, says the current restrictions on fishing in dolphin waters around New Zealand are already significant, with 15,000 square kilometres of ocean already closed.
“The seafood industry has devoted a great deal of time, effort and money into reducing risks to marine mammals and will continue to do so.
“However, any further restrictions must be based on sound science, unlike the current proposition. This is no longer about dolphins. It is an environmentally-driven, anti-fishing agenda that gives no consideration to the livelihoods of fishermen and their families.
“Yet the proposal has no socio-economic analysis. What about the wellbeing of our fishers?,” said Pankhurst.
The paucity of science behind the current proposals was highlighted recently at a meeting attended by Fisheries NZ and around 200 locals at Kawhia (August 2). The proposed set net ban for all west coast harbours from Maunganui Bluff to New Plymouth threatened to close those fishermen down, yet no Maui dolphin had ever been seen in the Kawhia Harbour.
“The fishermen affected by this proposal are not large corporates. They are the people who supply your local fish and chip shop. They are fishing small, inshore quota, many the result of Treaty settlements. All of these fishers are committed to protecting the environment and biodiversity. They hate the thought of catching a dolphin and their fishing practices reflect that.”
The consultation paper dispassionately states that hundreds of fishers will be ‘affected’.
“That means wiped out,” said Pankhurst. “There is no discussion in the document on human impacts, compensation or transitional assistance. What’s proposed in the dolphin TMP is simply to close down vast areas of the coast to fishing and forget about the fishers, their families, the processing facilities and the wider communities they support, right across New Zealand.
“Seafood New Zealand strongly supports efforts to save the Maui and to further protect their more numerous close relative, the Hector’s dolphin. We support the appropriate extension of scientifically based exclusion zones, the use of dolphin deterring technology, the enhanced use of observers and the current camera trial.
“What we cannot countenance is the obliteration of small fishing operators and what amounts to theft of property and Treaty rights,” said Pankhurst.
Read Seafood New Zealand's submission on the Hector's and Maui dolphin TMP here.
ends

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

Record Dry Spells And Effects On Forests – Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
Official Cash Rate Remains At 1.0 Percent
By: The Reserve Bank of New Zealand
Climate Change Throws Tree Seeding Out Of Sync – New Study
By: University of Canterbury
Novel coronavirus detected in China –Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
Flooding could release toxic gas – Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
More Rain For The South While Dry Continues In The North
By: MetService
Another dry week ahead, with temperatures rising
By: MetService
Auckland Set To Break Dry Spell Record
By: NIWA
Rolleston Fire
By: Fire and Emergency NZ
Farmers Fear New Water Rules Could Push Them Under
By: RNZ
The OCR Should Be Cut
By: Michael Reddell
MPS, OCR and FSR dates for 2021
By: Reserve Bank
Reserve Bank Of New Zealand Keeps Official Cash Rate At 1 Percent
By: RNZ
XE Morning Update
By: XE Morning Update
Economic Growth Slowing Under Coalition Government
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media