INDEPENDENT NEWS

Standards Committee issues decision: Catriona MacLennan

Published: Tue 15 May 2018 12:47 PM
Standards Committee issues decision about lawyer who said a Judge was not fit to sit on the bench.
A Lawyers Standards Committee has decided to take no further action against a lawyer who said it was inappropriate for a District Court Judge to continue to serve on the bench.
Auckland Barrister, Catriona MacLennan’s statements were the subject of an investigation following her public criticism of Judge John Brandts-Giesen.
Judge Brandts-Giesen discharged a Queenstown man without conviction in a domestic violence case last year. The man had assaulted his wife, a male friend and his daughter.
The judge said, ‘This is a situation that does your wife no credit and does the [male] no credit’ and ‘there would be many people who would have done exactly what you did, even though it may be against the law to do so.’
A member of the public complained about Ms MacLennan’s criticism of the judge, prompting the committee to investigate.
Acting Executive Director of the New Zealand Law Society Mary Ollivier says the Standards Committee considered the explanation Ms MacLennan provided for her comments.
“It accepted that lawyers can express their views on the performance of judges but that those comments must be considered and not cross a line that could cause the public to lose confidence in the role of the judiciary and the role judges play in the administration of justice. The committee did not consider that Ms MacLennan’s comments had crossed that line. Her experience as an advocate for victims of domestic violence and the sentiment in which the comments were made were factors in the decision,” Mrs Ollivier says.
Mrs Ollivier says the high level of interest in this investigation by the public and the profession warranted the rare move of releasing the full decision by the Standards Committee.

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

Australian bushfires continue to blaze – Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
Higher retail consumption lifts GDP
By: Statistics New Zealand
Fairer pay with minimum wage rise for quarter of a million
By: New Zealand Government
Tourism and Environment: Pristine, popular... imperilled?
By: Parliamentary Commissioner For The Environment
Gordon Campbell on the Aussie bush fires and Suleimani
By: Gordon Campbell
Bushfire Crisis: Climate Politics Turning Point Aus Needs?
By: The Conversation
Scott Morrison: the bushfires demand a climate policy reboot
By: The Conversation
Incendiary Extinctions: Australian Fires
By: Binoy Kampmark
Aussie bushfire smoke reaches NZ – update 2nd Jan 2020
By: NIWA
2019 NZ's fourth warmest year on record - Expert Reaction
By: Science Media Centre
2019 second hottest year on record, UN confirms
By: UN News
Fossil Fuel Companies Called On To Foot Australia Fires Bill
By: Eoin Higgins
GDP growth reflects a strong economy
By: New Zealand Government
NZ in ‘GDP per person recession’ under Labour
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media