Press Release
26 May 2017
Electricity retailers welcome low fixed-charge tariff review
Electricity retailers welcome a review of the low fixed-charge tariff, as announced by Energy Minister Judith Collins
this week.
The Chief Executive of the Electricity Retailers Association of New Zealand (ERANZ), Jenny Cameron, says retailers agree
with the Minister that the fact that some of the poorest people are cross-subsidising wealthier households because of
the low fixed charges is the opposite of what was intended when they were introduced in 2004, and therefore warrants a
review.
“Retailers have been calling for some time for the low fixed-charge to be looked at, so asking the Ministry of Business,
Innovation and Employment (MBIE) to review it is a welcome development.
“The International Energy Agency highlighted in their 2017 report on New Zealand’s energy sector that a review was
needed. They identified that artificially low fixed charges result in some customers paying higher tariffs for their
electricity consumption and have the potential to distort the market at the expense of consumers.
“In March, Concept Consulting released a report that covered the social impact of the low fixed charge. That report
found that while helping some poorer consumers, much of the benefit flows to middle- and higher-income consumers.
“The report estimated that only 5 per cent of the total benefit flows to households in the most deprived category. The
low fixed-charge scheme also hurts those poorer households that have average or above-average electricity usage.
“This charge needs to be replaced if we are to do better by low-income households.
“Retailers are willing to work with MBIE and other government agencies to find a more targeted solution for those who
need the most help to meet their energy needs.
“It’s a complex issue. It’s linked to income, housing quality, and appropriate appliances, as well as education and
behaviour, and needs to be looked at with a cross-sectoral, targeted investment approach involving the public and
private sector.”
ends