Financial Services Council commissions report on personal insurance sales incentives
The Financial Services Council (FSC) has commissioned consulting actuaries Melville Jessup Weaver (MJW) to investigate
sales incentives in the personal insurance industry (life and income protection insurance) and to suggest remedies for
any misalignment of incentives between salespeople and their clients.
FSC CEO Peter Neilson said New Zealanders often switch their policies between companies because their new policy is
better value, has better coverage or is being provided by a company with a better solvency rating or better claims
record. “Churn” occurs when a policy is switched to the benefit of the salespeople but not the customer such as a switch
that results in the customer losing coverage for a pre-existing condition.
The personal insurance sector is currently responding to these issues in a Section 25 information request from the
Financial Markets Authority (FMA) and the review of the Financial Advisers Act being undertaken by the Ministry of
Business Innovation and Employment (MBIE).
“We expect the MJW independent report will identify possible solutions for these issues,” said Mr Neilson. “The FSC aims
to have its own firm recommendations available by the time we submit on the Financial Advisers Act Review proposals
later this year.”
He said MJW had been asked to consult widely on the issues and possible solutions. Based on earlier Massey University
research the FSC believes New Zealanders are underinsured when it comes to life cover and even more so in respect of
income protection insurance.
Mr Neilson said the products the industry sells address issues like premature death and unexpected serious illness that
prevents earning an income, issues that most people would prefer not to talk about. As those products are sold not
bought, the industry mainly relies on an agent and broker distribution channel.
“For that reason MJW is already meeting with agent and broker organisations to discuss the issues, options and
opportunities. The FSC and its members want solutions that can receive wide buy in from consumers, producers, agents and
brokers.”
Earlier this year MJW brought to New Zealand John Trowbridge who undertook a similar exercise in Australia and he will
be an adviser to MJW for the project.
ENDS