Poor outlook for conservative KiwiSavers
KiwiSaver members in conservative funds are in for poor returns, according to a new report by the New Zealand Institute
of Economic Research.
In its inaugural New Zealand Investment Quarterly (NZIQ), NZIER expects conservative funds to barely outperform cash
over the next seven years.
Conservative funds, including the nine KiwiSaver default funds, mostly invest in sovereign (government) bonds and cash
while allocating only a small proportion to shares.
They are expected to return only 4.6% per year to 2022, compared to the expected average 90-day bank bill rate of 4.2%.
“NZIER believes sovereign bonds will perform poorly in the medium term, which would drag down the returns from
conservative funds,” says the author of the NZIQ report, NZIER Principal Economist Aaron Drew.
Balanced funds, which invest less in government bonds and cash and more in shares, are expected to return 5.6% per year
while growth funds, which mostly invest in shares, are expected to achieve an average return of 6.5%.
These returns are all much lower that have been enjoyed over the past few years, and reflects the NZIER’s view that
markets across the board are no longer cheap. These returns are gross of fees and taxes.
“Conservative funds have performed very well in the low rate environment we have seen since the GCF hit, but they are
likely to significantly underperform growth funds in the long term,” Drew says.
“There is a cyclical aspect to our forecast: we believe bonds, particularly sovereign bonds, are vulnerable to a
correction when interest rates globally start to rise.”
Drew says funds will benefit from greater exposure to share markets and some alternative asset classes, which are
expected to fare better than bonds in the medium term.
“Equities are looking like a mixed bag, with Europe, Japan and the UK offering better value than the US, Australia,
Canada and New Zealand markets.”
Drew is hoping the NZIQ will re-ignite discussion about asset allocation in KiwiSaver, which in his view is too highly
weighted to income assets such as cash and bonds.
Conservative and moderate funds account for almost 44% of the $27 billion measured in the latest Morningstar KiwiSaver
Survey.
“Over 40 years, the difference between a growth fund and a default fund could add up to tens or even hundreds of
thousands of dollars for a KiwiSaver investor,” Drew says.
“There has been a lot of public discussion about KiwiSaver contribution rates and what is required to achieve a
comfortable retirement, but members will not get the most out of the scheme if they are in the wrong type of fund for
their risk profile and investment horizon.”
ENDS