8 August 2014
Labour’s water crusade
Federated Farmers is asking why the Hon David Cunliffe is talking about helping regional economies on one hand, while
announcing new taxes on those same regions to knock them back on the other.
“This is a thinly disguised anti-farming policy that is trying to blame farmers and particularly farmers who irrigate,
for all of New Zealand’s water problems,” says Ian Mackenzie, Federated Farmers Environment spokesperson.
“It is clearly misguided and worse it is opening the divide between town and country when we should be working together.
“They know they cannot bring all rivers and lakes up to swimming standards without rebuilding all urban storm water
systems and clearing New Zealand of wildfowl at all, let alone, in 25 years.
“Taxing irrigators in Canterbury and Otago to fix up degraded waterways in other parts of the country seems patently
unfair.
“As for the practical effect of their anti-farming Resource Rental policy, it can be summarised in Northland, Auckland
and the Bay of Plenty as being principally a tax on horticulture.
“In Marlborough and I guess in parts of Hawke’s Bay plus Wairarapa too, it is a tax on grapes as well as fruit and
vegetables.
“For the rest of us, it is a tax on wheat, vegetables and pasture production.
“Independent economic modelling indicates that a Resource Rental on water at one-cent per cubic metre of water takes $39
million out of farms and provincial economies.
“This is all money that farmers are currently spending on protecting rivers and streams. Money that is making the towns
of Ashburton, Pleasant Point and Oamaru places of employment for thousands of people. The same provincial economies that
David Cunliffe wants to help.
“I don’t understand how you can help those towns by punitively taxing the one thing that has driven some prosperity in
those regions.
“The Greens want to beat up dairy farmers, Labour wants to do it to irrigators. When will these people realise that
others in New Zealand take and pollute water as well.
“Irrigation may take 57 percent of water used but residential and industrial users take 43 percent according to Labour’s
own source document. It seems a bit one sided to continuously blame only one sector of the community for effects caused
by everyone.
“As New Zealanders we need to collectively own up to our responsibilities and work together if we are to make a
difference.
“Farmers have done that. It is time Labour and the Greens recognised that and argued for policies that encouraged the
rest of New Zealand to do so too,” Mr Mackenzie.