"Budget 2014 was the first budget in many years to be delivered in what could be called “normal” economic conditions.
New Zealand’s economic growth for the forseeable future is modest but robust, underpinned by the Christchurch rebuild,
record high terms of trade and high producer and consumer confidence. These are conditions that many of our trading
partners (not least Australia) would crawl over broken glass to enjoy. But the rosy outlook is not without its risks and
it is management of these risks that seems to have been front of mind for Bill English." - Aaron Quintal, Tax Partner EY NZ
Government Has Learnt a GFC Lesson
So the government kept its promise to return to surplus, just. The surplus is forecast at $372 million for 2014/15 and
expected to grow to $3.5 billion in 2017/18. The surplus is being driven by both increased tax revenues and government
expenditure growing slower than the rest of the economy.
Crown tax revenue is expected to reach $77.6 billion by 2017/18, $18.9 billion higher than 2012/13 driven mostly through
growth in PAYE and GST. Core Crown expenses are expected to increase in nominal terms by $11.1 billion from 2014 to
2018, but this is slower than forecast economic growth, so as a percentage of GDP Crown expenses should fall from 33% of
GDP in 2012/13 to 29.9% in 2017/18.
Keeping a watchful eye
Budget 2014 was the first budget in many years to be delivered in what could be called “normal” economic conditions. New
Zealand’s economic growth for the forseeable future is modest (peaking at 4%) but robust, underpinned by the
Christchurch rebuild (which is taking longer than first anticipated), record high (but declining) terms of trade and
high producer and consumer confidence (sustained by a strong labour market and growth in key trading partners). These
are conditions that many of our trading partners (not least Australia) would crawl over broken glass to enjoy. But the
rosy outlook is not without its risks and it is management of these risks that seems to have been front of mind for Bill
English.
At the start of the GFC, New Zealand’s net Crown debt was an enviable 5.5% of GDP. This low net debt, and the headroom
it gave the government to run deficits and borrow during the bad times, played a key part of New Zealand coming through
the GFC in a much better position than many of our contemporaries.
Rebuilding the all-important buffer
The government has learned an important lesson from this experience and wants to rebuild that buffer for the future. It
is clear that nothing will take priority over getting the level of debt down. Any hints of tax cuts or promises of
restarting contributions to the New Zealand Superannuation Fund are foremost contingent on getting net debt down. If the
economy does better than is expected over the next few years, that extra money will go back to repaying lenders well
before there is any sniff of tax cuts.
Barring a major disaster (natural or financial) the government certainly hopes to deliver what the Minister called
“modest” tax cuts. The earliest these can practically be delivered within the constraint of getting net debt down is
2018/19.
Low rates are not forever
Interest rates remain a major risk for the economy. The remarkably low interest rates we have had since the GFC will not
continue. The government is forecasting short-term interest rates rising from their current level of 2.5% to 4.3% in
March 2015 and rising even higher in the future. Any increase above this level will stifle growth and hurt the
government’s revenue forecasts. With inflation expected to peak at 2.5% in 2016, the government doesn’t want to do
anything that would further fuel inflation. The advice they have received is $1.5 billion growth in spending each year
is all the economy can take before inflation becomes an issue and interest rates rise even further.
Given the way the economy is heading, the best the government hoped to do in this Budget was get out of the road and let
the economy do its thing.
*************
Aaron Quintal is a tax partner in the EY Auckland office and leader of the Tax Policy Group. Aaron is a regular presenter at conferences and media commentator. He is also the editor of EY's Tax Watch newsletter.
ENDS