Fonterra’s Fixed Or Floating Trial While a Big Day Approache
MEDIA RELEASE
1 May
2013
Fonterra’s Fixed Or
Floating Trial While a Big Day
Approaches
Fonterra Cooperative Group’s
trial of a Guaranteed Milk Price (GMP) scheme comes with
shareholders from tomorrow, being able to indicate how many
economic rights they wish to sell to the Fonterra
Shareholders’ Fund.
“Ten out of ten for
Fonterra trying something new with its Guaranteed Milk
Price,” says Willy Leferink, Federated Farmers Dairy
Chairperson.
“In most seasons, excepting the
global meltdown of 2008/9, I have the suspicion farmer-
shareholders would have ended up being out of pocket if they
had ‘fixed’ their payout at the season opening.
“Aside from one or two hiccups, we have
generally seen forecasts rise towards a season’s
end.
“Take the current 2012/13 season. The
opening forecast was in the $5.95-$6.05 range per kilogram
of milk solids (kg/MS) but $6.12 kg/MS is looking more
likely. For the average herd under GMP that difference
adds up to being between $7,500 and some
$18,000.
“GMP is a risk management tool but it is
seemingly one more for the cooperative than
farmer-shareholders. For farmers to fix intelligently,
they would need to take into account seasonal weather
outlooks here and overseas, global markets and what the
dollar may do.
“In other words, the sorts of
complex risk management farmers rely on the cooperative for
and expressed through the forecast payout. Federated
Farmers would be concerned if GMP implied there was going to
be less accurate forecasts going forward.
“On top
of this announcement and from tomorrow, Fonterra’s
farmer-shareholders will be able to sell their economic
rights in up to a quarter of their production based
“Wet” shares to the Fonterra Shareholders’ Fund, or
FSF.
“As the FSF is currently trading at $7.81
per unit, farmers may be tempted to take the money seemingly
on offer. Doing that marks a shift in the cooperative’s
ethos. Yet farmer-shareholders also need to know that the
price won’t be set until 16 May.
“The FSF unit
price today may not be the farmer price come 16 May. This
is a big chunk of a Fonterra farmer-shareholder’s equity
so they need to think long and hard before
committing.
“Federated Farmers echoes
Fonterra’s advice and that is to spend money on quality
independent financial advice,” Mr Leferink
concluded.
ENDS