TOWER Limited – Red zone case settled

Published: Fri 19 Apr 2013 12:20 PM
TOWER Limited – Red zone case settled
Rob Flannagan, TOWER’s Group Managing Director, said today the company was pleased to have reached a settlement with Mr and Mrs O’Loughlin whose earthquake-damaged house was in Christchurch’s red zone.
“We are pleased that this matter has been settled. The Court decision issued earlier this month confirmed all the points of principle that TOWER had sought a ruling on, while also granting the O’Loughlins a re-calculation of their pay-out.
“We welcomed the clarity that the decision provided, and now look forward to all concerned with this case being able to move on,” he said. The terms of the settlement were confidential.
Background to the case
What the case was about
Because their house was in the red zone Mr and Mrs O’Loughlin argued for a full replacement pay-out irrespective of actual physical damage to the house.
TOWER defended the action because it believed its pay-out honoured the policy, there were important principles at stake and the amount initially sought of $1.3 million was too high.
The two key issues were: Whether a house in the red zone is a total loss, which would require insurers to pay to replace the house, regardless of the physical damage sustained. Whether the pay-out offered to the O’Loughlins on the basis of a proposed repair was calculated correctly by TOWER.
There was never any question of the owners continuing to live in the red zone. They had already sold the site to the government, and TOWER was prepared to settle their claim with cash.
What the judgement found
Justice Asher gave an interim judgment on the case in the Christchurch High Court on 5 April.
The Court confirmed that the creation of the red zone did not render all houses within it a total loss. The Court agreed that it was TOWER’s choice as to whether it repaired, replaced or rebuilt the house. It determined that on the facts of this case TOWER’s proposed methodology to repair the O’Loughlins home was not reasonably proven. The Judge was not persuaded that the proposed low mobility grouting (LMG) repair for the house would get a building consent. Given that the Court was not persuaded that the repair methodology met TOWER’s obligations, it determined TOWER was entitled to choose to pay either:
o the cost of building a comparable new house on good ground outside the red zone; or
o the cost of buying a comparable existing house (excluding land value) outside the red zone. The Court confirmed that the O’Loughlins were not entitled to the higher costs of rebuilding on their red zoned land as those costs would not in fact be incurred.
The judgment had provided a good process for resolving this case and clarity on how to calculate insurance pay-outs in the red zone.
“TOWER’s intention is to settle every claim quickly and fairly with our policyholders and we are pleased that this matter has now been resolved,” Mr Flannagan said. Ends

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

Snail's pace: Aucklanders face frustrating commute over Harbour Bridge
COVID-19 Sees Record 12.2 Percent Fall In New Zealand’s Economy
By: Statistics New Zealand
Scientists Release ‘Blueprint’ To Save Critical Ecosystems And Stabilize The Earth’s Climate
By: Joint Press Release
Independent Review Launched Into Assurances For Safe Transport Of Livestock By Sea
By: Ministry For Primary Industries
New Zealand PC Market Grows Nearly 40% Due To Work From Home Demand
By: IDC New Zealand Ltd
Public Transport Distancing Requirements Relaxed
By: Ministry of Health
New Zealand Hemp Industry Set To Generate $2 Billion Per Annum And Create 20,000 Jobs
By: New Zealand Hemp Industries Association Inc
One In 14 Employed People Report High Risk Of Losing Jobs
By: Statistics New Zealand
ASB Quarterly Economic Forecast Shows NZ Economy Doing Better Than Expected, But Challenges Remain
Live Export Ship Carrying 5,800 New Zealand Cows Goes Missing In East China Sea
FMA Releases Report Into Active And Passive Fund Management
By: Financial Markets Authority
Engineers Assess Damage To Auckland Harbour Bridge After Truck Strike
By: NZ Transport Agency
Motorists Urged To Avoid Damaged Auckland Harbour Bridge
By: NZ Transport Agency
Harbour Bridge: Public Transport A Great Option And Plan Ahead
By: Auckland Transport
Second Harbour Crossing Needed Now, More Than Ever
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media