8 October 2009
New Zealand tax decision handed down
Tax assessments for nine structured finance transactions undertaken between 1998 and 2002 have been the subject of
proceedings between Westpac Banking Corporation (“Westpac”) and the Commissioner of Inland Revenue (“CIR”) New Zealand.
The proceedings challenged amended assessments issued by the CIR in respect of Westpac’s tax treatment of these
transactions. The judgment released by the High Court in Auckland found in favour of the CIR on four representative
transactions. When taking into account all of the nine transactions the financial cost of the judgment would be NZ$918
million (A$753 million), made up of core tax of NZ$586 million and interest of NZ$332 million (all as at 30 September
2009)
Westpac NZ CEO, George Frazis said: “The length of the trial, the time taken to consider arguments, and the time taken
to get to this stage, clearly demonstrate the complexity of the issues being contested.”
"We have always believed that the transactions were commercially justified and complied with the law. This is
particularly so because Westpac obtained a ruling in 2001 from the CIR in respect of a similar transaction which
confirmed Westpac's view that a transaction of this type satisfied all tax laws and in particular was not tax avoidance.
We are very disappointed with this decision.”
Mr Frazis said that Westpac would take time to go through the detail of the judgment and would be considering an appeal.
The Westpac Group will consider appropriate provisions as part of its Full Year 2009 results, to be announced on 4
November 2009. Should Westpac increase its existing tax provisions to NZ$918 million, this would impact Westpac’s Tier 1
capital ratio by approximately 25 basis points. Any change in provisions will not be included in cash earnings.
“The Westpac Group maintains a Tier 1 ratio well above its target range and is able to meet any additional tax that may
be payable as a result of the judgment,” Mr Frazis said. “This judgment will not impact our day to day operations in any
way.”
ends_______________________________________________________________