Government call for Consumer Choice ignored by FSANZ
Soil & Health is appalled at the lack of consumer choice from Food Standards Australia New Zealand’s (FSANZ) mandatory folic
acid fortification of bread Proposal released on Friday evening.
The proposal is for effectively all bread to have synthetic folic acid added.
With no meaningful exceptions in the proposal, Soil & Health is calling on the Minister of Food Safety Annette King to use her influence for at least organic breads to be
exempt to allow consumers choice.
At the recent Baking Industry Association of New Zealand conference the Minister expressed the need for choice and the
difficulty for bakers with the all bread proposal and I know she has heard consumers, said Soil & Health spokesperson Steffan Browning.
Mass medication is not wanted by New Zealanders and New Zealand Government submissions to FSANZ were clear about that,
but that message has been effectively ignored. New Zealand studies mentioned, found the majority of participants were
opposed to mandatory fortification with folic acid.
The FSANZ Board has effectively rejected a strong submission* supporting the need for consumer choice from the New
Zealand Food Safety Authority (NZFSA).
Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT), Ministry of Economic Development (MED), and the Ministry of Consumer
Affairs supported the wide-ranging submission. The Ministry of Health (MoH) supported the submission in principle.
While varying from the Soil & Health submission that called for a full exemption for organic products from the synthetic folic acid, NZFSA had
certainly listened to consumer concerns and looked for a middle way through, said Mr Browning. Soil & Health remains committed to helping organic consumers and small bakers find a solution to this draconian proposal.
There have yet to be any publicly funded campaigns in New Zealand promoting naturally folate-rich foods or folic acid
supplements to address the incidence of neural tube defects.
Foods naturally high in folate are green leafy vegetables (such as broccoli and spinach), nuts,
orange juice, some fruits and dried beans and peas. Cereals are moderate sources of folate.
With children to be the more likely victims of excessive folate levels and health issues around excessive folate levels
unresolved, choice and education are a better solution.
This FSANZ proposal leaves consumers baking their own bread as the only real option if wanting a choice. This is not
acceptable to most organic consumers who like other consumers rely on commercial bakers for their synthetic free daily
bread.
“My baker of choice uses no additives at all,” said Mr Browning “ and this decision takes no account of the natural
folate already existing above average in the wholesome organic loaves.”
The FSANZ proposal says
“Mandatory folic acid fortification may be an issue for bakeries producing artisan breads using only ‘natural
ingredients’, and for organic bread manufacturers. Artisan bakers may consider the fortification of their products will
not fit with their niche market, and could be seen as detrimental to sales. Folic acid may not be considered a ‘natural
ingredient’ as it is a synthetic form of folate, and may also conflict with organic industry standards.”
FSANZ’ could use Standards New Zealand’s Organic Standard for a definition of organic to allow an exception, according
to Soil & Health’s Steffan Browning, “Consumer choice would be the better for it.”
Soil & Health calls on Minister of Food Safety Annette King, New Zealand’s representative on the Australia and New Zealand
Food Regulation Ministerial Council, to insist on real consumer choice by way of a review of this proposal at the
Council’s next meeting on 25th October 2006.
Steffan Browning
Spokesperson
The Soil & Health Association of New Zealand Inc
ENDS