Tough Cannabis Laws "No Deterrent' - Australian Study
Fri, 06 Aug 1999
The Hemp Store
"The study, which compared Western Australia's prohibitive cannabis laws with the liberal cautioning system used in
South Australia, found that the social costs of minor cannabis offences under a punitive system could be much worse than
any health effects suffered by users."
Source: Sydney Morning Herald (Australia)
Date: Thu, 05 Aug 1999
Contact: letters@smh.fairfax.com.au
Website: http://www.smh.com.au/
Author: Paola Totaro
TOUGH DRUG LAWS 'NO DETERRENT'
Tough anti-cannabis laws fail to deter most offenders from using the drug again and can often have serious long-term
social costs, including relationship breakdowns and loss of employment, a study has found.
The report also says prohibitive drug laws often mean that offenders caught with small amounts of the drug are more
likely to become further involved with the police.
The study, which compared Western Australia's prohibitive cannabis laws with the liberal cautioning system used in South
Australia, found that the social costs of minor cannabis offences under a punitive system could be much worse than any
health effects suffered by users.
The study was conducted by researchers from the South Australian Drug and Alcohol Services Council and Curtin
University's National Centre for Research into the Prevention of Drug Abuse.
It forms part of a four-year national study into the social impact of cannabis legislation which has been undertaken by
researchers from NSW, Victorian, South Australian and Western Australian universities and funded by the Commonwealth
Department of Health and Aged Care.
The results of the reports are likely to have a major impact on national drug policy talks on cannabis laws. They come
in the wake of the NSW Government's decision to introduce a trial police caution system for minor cannabis offences
while the Victorian Government fears the end of a 12-month pilot of similar, even more liberal laws.
A research fellow at the centre, Mr Simon Lenton, said the health risks of cannabis use were often debated in the media
but little was said about the social harms associated with a conviction.
He said previous research at the centre had shown that each day, two to three West Australians were given a criminal
record as a direct result of being arrested for possession or use of a small amount of cannabis.
"The latest findings show a conviction for a minor cannabis offence can have real and detrimental impacts on people's
lives for many years after the event that are far worse than those due to an infringement notice under the South
Australian system," he said.
The study concluded that receiving a criminal conviction and record resulted in negative experiences for first time
cannabis users and their families. It found:
* Neither a cannabis conviction nor an infringement notice had much impact on interviewees' subsequent cannabis use,
with 90 per cent saying it had not led them to cut down on their cannabis use.
* Many minor cannabis offenders in South Australia and Western Australia appeared to be otherwise law abiding.
* Some 32 per cent of the West Australian group compared with only 2 per cent of the South Australian infringement
notice group were sacked from a job, did not get a job they applied for or stopped applying for some jobs as a result of
their conviction.
* The study showed 20 per cent of the West Australian group compared with 5 percent of the South Australia infringement
notice group experienced relationship problems.
* Some 16 per cent of the West Australian group had to move house or lost accommodation as a result of their conviction
compared to none in South Australia.
* It found 32 per cent of the West Australian group identified at least one later involvement with the criminal justice
system which they related to their cannabis conviction, possibly because they had become known to police from that first
conviction.
NORML New Zealand
PO Box 3307 Auckland
http://www.norml.org.nz
Subscribe [or unsubscribe] to NORML News Online!
Send mailto:hempstor@ihug.co.nz with 'subscribe' [or 'unsubscribe'] in subject line