Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Lack Of Volcano Monitoring Increases ‘Existential Risk’
Whakatāne Mayor Victor Luca says a lack of monitoring of Whakaari-White Island is putting the whole Eastern Bay community at an increased risk in the case of a major eruption.
During increased activity on the island recently, he wrote a letter with his concerns to Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and relevant ministers. It was co-signed by other Eastern Bay mayors, Ōpōtiki district’s David Moore and Kawerau’s Faylene Tunui, raising these concerns.
The letter asked for ministerial intervention to allow GNS Science to have access to the island to install monitoring equipment.
Dr Luca says he was first made aware of the absence of on-island monitoring at a Bay of Plenty Emergency Management Group meeting in April.
GNS Science principal scientist Graham Leonard, in an article published in May, said a lack of access to the island since the December 2019 eruption meant the last functioning seismo-acoustic station there stopped working completely in August 2022.
He said without on-island monitoring, the organisation’s ability to detect and confirm eruptions at Whakaari was limited.
All monitoring of the volcano was now done remotely through stations on the mainland, observation flights, and satellite technology.
Dr Luca said the eruption that killed 22 people in 2019 was considered a relatively minor one.
If there was a major eruption on Whakaari it would have serious consequences for people on the mainland due to the effects of ash, he said.
“We live not very far off the coast of quite an active volcano which has been, throughout its history, reasonably tame. We haven’t had volcanic eruptions that have covered the mainland in ash.
"When I was living in Argentina, a volcano went up in the Andean mountains and some ash was received in Buenos Aires, which is about 1400 kilometres away. Nearby towns had ash up to their knees in some places.”
Whakaari is just 48 kilometres from the mainland.
“Any volcano can go off at any time with no notice but by monitoring we can have a chance of getting some notice,” Dr Luca said.
“The beast has been well behaved for a long time and I hope it stays that way.
"If there’s a method of getting advanced notice we should have it. It’s an existential threat for the town. When they’re not monitoring it, our risks are enhanced.”
Dr Luca said he received a response from Minister of Emergency Management Mark Mitchell thanking the three mayors for their “diligence and concern” on behalf of their communities.
Mr Mitchell agreed with the concerns raised and had asked the National Emergency Management Agency to provide him with advice on how to expedite the placement of GNS monitoring on the island.
Multi-agency work was taking place, which included NEMA, Department of Internal Affairs, Ministry of Transport, Civil Aviation Authority, GNS Science, Emergency Management Bay of Plenty, Bay of Plenty Regional Council.
The group also plans to invite Ngāti Awa to join.
Local Democracy Reporting
Content from the Local Democracy Reporting (LDR) service is published by Scoop as a registered New Zealand Media Outlet LDR Partner.
Gordon Campbell: On What’s Wrong With The Treaty Principles Bill
Mana Mokopuna: Children And Young People Share Vital Insights On Healing From Family Violence And Sexual Violence In New Report
NZ Government: PM Marks One Year In Government
Helen Clark Foundation: Helen Clark Foundation Calls For Political Action To Reduce The Prevalence Of Junk Food And Improve Health Outcomes
Justice Committee: Further Decisions About Submissions Process For The Principles Of The Treaty Of Waitangi Bill
Infrastructure New Zealand: Single Agency Needed To Coordinate Climate Adaptation And Recovery
Free Speech Union: Fair Digital News Bargaining Bill Likely To Restrict Access To Information, Polling Shows Most Oppose
