Quarry Risk To Tranz Alpine Train, But No Quick Fix

Published: Sat 11 May 2024 07:03 PM
A view of the abandoned Kiwi Point Quarry, with the rock outcrop dubbed a hazard, right, and the Kiwi Point rail overbridge and State highway 7, bottom.  PICTURES: SUPPLIED, West Coast Regional Council
Delays in the decommissioning of dangerous rock quarry near Greymouth has raised the ire of a West Coast Regional councillor.
A fresh report on the mothballed Kiwi Point Quarry this week to council's Infrastructure Governance Group did not go down well with Cr Peter Ewen.
He said the risk to the public from the site had already been on the radar for at least six years and the fresh report -- following a geotechnical report in mid-2022 -- made no reference to the abandoned underground mine shafts dating back to the 1920s beneath the site, Cr Ewen, a recognised West Coast mine historian, said.
The site remains on notice from Work Safe.
Cr Ewen said the risk of the site's collapse onto the Tranz Alpine tourist train route and State highway 7 had been well signalled -- as seen in June 2022 when the train ran into a slip below the quarry access road.
"The risk is there. Furthermore, in 2018 it was highlighted it would effect the State highway and the Tranz Alpine. Well, in 2022 the train hit a slip there -- under the bridge."
The Tranz Alpine hit a slip beneath the Kiwi Point rail overbridge in June 2022. That incident was relatively minor but, "heaven forbid we have a large slip and another train or vehicle gets caught", Cr Ewen said.
"I'm pretty disappointed with (the report) actually because historically there has been front page stories on this site.
"There's quite a void there and to not have that included in a report is a deficiency I'm not prepared to accept.
Council ceased operating the quarry about 2020 after 45 years of extraction.
Since then part of the access road has been removed to deal with the slip risk onto the road and railway below.
"I've raised this before … the risk is sub-surface.
"The deficiency of not having that in those official reports is not right. I object to receiving these like this," Cr Ewen said.
Cr Ewen said "a big cavernous shaft" in the area escalated the risk yet council now had two reports which failed to appraise that.
Cr Ewen has repeatedly raised the risk to council staff in public meetings in the past two years.
He said his concerns could be verified by historic mine maps and the issue was well known locally.
A staff report said the latest consultant study recommended "an extensive amount of work which will be costly".
Acting catchments manager Shanti Morgan said another "risk assessment" on the quarry's current status, as well as on the necessary work to make it safe, were recommended.
That would allow for cost estimates to formally decommission the site, Ms Morgan said.
Council chief executive Darryl Lew said Cr Ewen should be tapped by staff to ensure the consultant was fully informed, pending an expanded report.
Committee chair Frank Dooley said while the latest report was based on scope, "if that scope is deficient that that is another issue."
"What Cr Ewen is saying, that is an issue."
Cr Peter Haddock agreed and said the quarry being above an historic mine was known, as was the risk from a local fault line nearby.
He also said the latest report effectively repeated the previous 2022 report.
Cr Brett Cummings said the latest report did identify a rock knob above the quarry as something council had to deal with given it was a fall risk.
"Council didn't put it there -- that seems unfair. That's going to be the dearest part, removing that natural feature."
Brendon McMahon - Local Democracy Reporter
Content from the Local Democracy Reporting (LDR) service is published by Scoop as a registered New Zealand Media Outlet LDR Partner.
Contact Lois Williams - Local Democracy Reporter

Next in New Zealand politics

New Fishing Rules Reflect Fishers’ Proactive Actions
By: Seafood New Zealand
Government To Reverse Blanket Speed Limit Reductions
By: New Zealand Government
Labour Supports Inquiry Into Rural Banking
By: New Zealand Labour Party
Govt Consulting On Cutting Red Tape For Exporters
By: New Zealand Government
Shane Jones Fires Damp Squib In Response To Giant Backlash Against Luxon’s War On Nature
By: Greenpeace
Government To Add Oil And Gas To Climate Fire
By: Green Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media