Farming company JB Thomas and Sons Limited has been convicted and fined a total of $71,250 for unlawfully discharging
dairy effluent into the environment at its Reporoa farm in November 2021.
The sentence was imposed by Chief Environment Court Judge David Kirkpatrick in the Rotorua District Court on 17 July
2023.
This is the company’s third such prosecution following similar convictions for pollution in 2001 and 2020.
The case was taken by Waikato Regional Council, under the Resource Management Act, following an inspection where
officers found the effluent storage pond on the property was full and had been overflowing. The overflow had run into a
farm drain that discharged into the Kopuhurihuri Stream, a tributary to the Waiotapu Stream.
This discharge also breached an abatement notice previously issued to the company by the council in 2019 directing the
company to manage its effluent lawfully.
In sentencing the company, Judge Kirkpatrick referred to “poor management” and commented that “the gravity of the
offending and the culpability of the defendant are moderately serious in this case”.
He added that “while not deliberate, I consider the defendant was clearly careless” and “the breach of an abatement
notice is a significant offence in itself as the process of issuing abatement notices has the purpose of avoiding repeat
offending”.