INDEPENDENT NEWS

Southland District Council defies logic to appeal

Published: Mon 5 Dec 2016 04:28 PM
Southland District Council defies logic to appeal
5 December 2016
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
“We’re obviously very disappointed”, says Graeme Watson, Southland Fish & Game chairman.
“The Environment Court process was robust, with the Judge and Commissioners undertaking a very detailed analysis of the evidence over four weeks of hearings”.
“Southland District Council (SDC) didn’t only have one or two aspects of their consents declined, they were comprehensively refused in every aspect that was in dispute. They were even criticised for not assessing the proposal against their own plans”.
“SDC consultants have misrepresented the Mararoa option throughout, which flows right through their economic analysis too. The Judge recognised that, but unfortunately the community keeps hearing figures from SDC consultants who only analysed what was a worst-case scenario for the Mararoa route. They’re comparing apples with onions”.
“We did all we could to avoid Environment Court and even offered to contribute funding towards the alternative Mararoa option. To now be dragged to the High Court is frustrating, knowing it’s costing time and money that would be better spent developing the alternative.”
“We’ve tried to be moderate in our comments thus far, but it’s time Southlanders recognised what a debacle this whole project has been, from Deloitte’s identifying a lack of expertise in the scoping and design of the trail options, to massive budget blow outs, to an unnecessary Environment Court case and now to the High Court.”
“The Environment Court judgement reviewed all the SDC’s evidence and concluded that the Mararoa offers viable alternatives, without any significant difference in projected economic benefit to Southland.
It’s a pity that SDC didn’t respect this Judge, accept the robust decision and move on. Instead they seem hell-bent on the Oreti, irrespective of the economic consequences to ratepayers and Southland as a whole”.
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on welfare vs infrastructure spending
By: Gordon Campbell
New direction for criminal justice reform
By: New Zealand Government
Surgical mesh restorative justice report received
By: New Zealand Government
Government’s power to order decryption must respect privacy
By: Joint Press Release
National will invest in quality healthcare
By: New Zealand National Party
Report on combatting foreign election interference delivered
By: RNZ
Name suppression lifted for officers A & B
By: New Zealand Police
Child Poverty Monitor: Big, bold, permanent change needed
By: Office of the Children's Commissioner
Chief Victims Advisor reappointed for a further two years
By: New Zealand Government
Justice report highlights systemic racism and inequality
By: Green Party
"The Best Christmas present ever"
By: Wellington Howard League
First Step toward Protecting Our First Responders
By: New Zealand First Party
Report: Stories of Survivors of Surgical Mesh
By: Ministry of Health
National will deliver high-quality care for women
By: New Zealand National Party
Surgical Mesh Restorative Justice Report Finally Released
By: Mesh Down Under
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media