Wellington Branch of the Public Health Association media release
Tuesday September 2016
How do Capital and Coast DHB candidates measure up?
A scorecard rating the Capital and Coast DHB candidates was released this evening by the Wellington Branch of the Public
Health Association. Voting is now open in the local body elections, allowing residents to vote for elected DHB
representatives for the coming term, as well as local government candidates.
“Health touches all of us, and the DHB is under pressure to cut costs, so voting for competent DHB candidates who will
make wise decisions is vital,” says Jude Ball, Chair of the Wellington branch of the Public Health Association. “The DHB
candidate profiles in the election handbook give voters little to go on, so the Public Health Association has provided
our own evaluation, based on a survey of candidates.”
“It’s great to see that out of the 20 candidates, there are some extremely experienced and competent individuals
standing,” says Ms Ball. “Based on our assessment of their survey responses, six candidates stood out as being
particularly strong: Eileen Brown, Grant Brookes, Roger Blakeley, Fran Wilde, Ian Scott and Sue Driver. All of them have
extensive relevant experience and knowledge. They understand that health is not just about hospitals, and they
prioritised preventive health measures including support for water fluoridation, in the survey.”
“Eileen Brown and Grant Brookes are both particularly strong on equity, and emphasised the importance of improving
outcomes for disadvantaged groups” say Ms Ball. Both have a nursing background. “The strongest candidates in terms of
governance experience are Fran Wilde and Roger Blakeley. Although neither of them has health sector experience, they
demonstrated a good understanding of the issues and put a strong emphasis on prevention, as did Ian Scott and Sue
Driver” says Ms Ball.
The scorecard rates candidates on their governance and health sector knowledge and experience, and their alignment with
Public Health Association policies in three key areas: water fluoridation, population health and equity. “The ratings
give a sense of the candidates’ alignment with Public Health Association policies and values. The PHA is about promoting
good health for everyone, based on evidence-informed public policy, and easy access to appropriate services, regardless
of income or ethnicity,” says Ms Ball.
“We acknowledge there are limitations to scoring candidates’ positions based only on survey results, especially for
complex issues like equity” say Ms Ball. “But, given the lack of information and debate about the DHB election, we hope
this might be a conversation starter.”
“Our scorecard rates candidates on the issues that are important to us as an organization, but we have published candidates’ full survey results on our website so that voters can see what
candidates have to say on other issues that might be important to them, for example mental health care or the living wage.”
The scorecard, along with details about how the scores were calculated, and the candidates’ survey answers in full are
available on the Public Health Association website www.pha.org.nz
The scorecard was released following a ‘meet the Capital and Coast DHB candidates’ event, hosted by the Public Health
Association this evening. The meeting was well attended, with 15 out of the 20 DHB candidates present, and four giving
apologies and providing a written statement. Questions from the audience focused on issues of fluoridation, mental
health care, and the challenges faced by the DHB.
Candidates talked the need for more funding, and many promised to advocate strongly to the Minister, if elected, to
increase the DHB’s budget. Several candidates spoke convincingly of the importance of community engagement, and the need
for a strong focus on prevention, including two long-standing DHB members who are standing for re-election, Sue Kedgely
and Helene Richie. Porirua’s Deputy Mayor, Ana Coffey, talked of the need for a community voice at the DHB table, and
said would represent Porirua, if elected.
The Public Health Association is a voluntary organisation whose goal is to improve the health of all New Zealanders by
promoting public health and influencing public policy. The Wellington Branch has about 70 members who work in research,
policy, health promotion, and in front line roles in health and social services.
Details for the Meet the CCDHB Candidates Meeting are: Tue 20 Sept, 6:00pm -7:30pm, St Johns Hall, Corner Willis and
Dixon Streets. Light refreshments provided, entry by koha.
Attachments (also available at www.pha.org.nz):
1. A4 PDF of the scorecard
2. Process and criteria for scoring the candidates
3. Candidates survey responses in full