Auditor General asked to review new Transport Rate
NoMoreRates has asked the Auditor General to review the consultation, or lack it, leading up to the decision by the
Auckland Council today in impose a $99 ‘levy’ on every household on top of the already announced 2.5% rates increase.
David Thornton. Founder of NoMoreRates, said today “The Mayor has totally ignored all the normal process of consultation
which requires adequate information be given to ratepayers when annual budgets are being prepared. I doubt if any
ratepayers would have guessed how big an increase in rates this temporary Transport Rate would mean”
“It may be too late to correct this situation, but at least I want the Auditor General to review the events and give an
opinion”
The text of the letter follows;-
I request that you revisit and review your audit of the Consultation on the Auckland Council Long Term Plan 2015 –
20125(LTP) in specific reference to the Interim Transport Levy..
My concern is , that despite your comments in your audit report, the consultation information on this new rate was, to
all intents and purposes, totally invisible and consequently the consultation process was badly flawed at best, and
unlawful at worst,
My evidence for this lies in the report from officials on the feedback to the Draft LTP presented to the Council’s
Budget Committee.
This report states that there were 27,383 written submissions on the Draft Plan of which only 39 mentioned the Interim
Targeted Rate, plus one multi-question survey by a ratepayers association.
I suggest that this level of response, to what has evolved into an average rate increase of more than 4%, clearly
indicates that insufficient information was placed before the public.
The information in the leaflet delivered to all households said, in relation to transport options, “Under either funding
option a targeted rate may also be required for 2015/2016”.
The formal Consultation Document is more informative and suggests a fixed charge of $58.99 per property or value-based
targeted rate – but only for the year 2015/2016 i.e. one year. (It must be acknowledge that very few ratepayers seek out
this formal Consultation Document)
What Council has decided is a ‘3-year interim levy’ at $99+ GST per residential property and $159 per business.
This outcome, in my view, is not what reasonable ratepayers could have envisaged from the information presented to them
in formal consultation.
I request that you consider and report on this information.
ends