Timing is everything!
Fri, Mar 07 2014
Isn’t it interesting that all the bad news being reported from Hawke’s Bay councils in the past week or so was actually
known last year — as in, pre-election?!
At the Regional Council, Andrew Newman’s performance evaluation and pay raise was on the agenda of the 25 September 2013
meeting. But the then-councillors, apparently not keen to award pay raises while facing re-election, deferred the
matter. Probably most of those sitting at the table at the time expected to be there for a routine approval at the
October meeting.
Over at the Hastings Council, the bad news about potential earthquake risk of the Opera House first surfaced in July of
last year. A closer look was recommended. But the HDC seemed to go into ‘let’s not hurry’ mode. And so the further
review, resulting in abrupt closure of the Opera House as unsafe, only arrived last week.
And at the Napier Council, internal concerns that the new museum would not be able to store the bulk of its collection
surfaced as early as June 2012. In July, museum director Douglas Lloyd Jenkins echoed the assessment of Opus
Consultants. Councillors were informed at least by October 2012 — in public excluded session, of course. The matter was
discussed at another public excluded session in February 2013. And then the matter went dead.
The minutes of the October 2012 meeting referred to “a major storage problem“.
The chairman of the Napier Council’s Finance Committee throughout this period was Bill Dalton. Yet, despite two reports,
what does he have to say?
“I had absolutely no idea of the potential size of the problem until just a couple of weeks ago.”
Remarkable … or should I say outrageous!? Here’s an $18 million civic project (partly funded by HBRC and HDC) and the
chairman of the Finance Committee claims he was unaware of the serious magnitude of the problem.
Either Mr Dalton has a ‘failure of recollection’ or was simply asleep at the wheel. In fairness though, the previous
Napier Council in its entirety was simply a stage prop for Mayor Arnott and then-Chief Executive Neil Taylor. No one on
that make-believe council questioned anything. It remains to be seen whether any of the newly elected councillors view
their role as anything other than passive onlookers.
Suppressed information … public excluded sessions … staff running the show — it’s all part of what has been
business-as-usual in local government Hawke’s Bay.
And no transparency equates to no accountability.
When councillors become mere cheerleaders for whatever their mayors, CEOs and council staffs are championing, instead of
serving as reasonably independent watchdogs, then the public had better be worried … whether it’s an opera house, a
museum, or a dam.
And with five councils operating this way in Hawke’s Bay, it’s far more than our region’s handful of citizen watchdogs
can keep track of or scrutinize.
As I see it, another reason for Transparent Hawke’s Bay.
And another reason for amalgamation.
Tom Belford
P.S. Find this too depressing? Here’s an antidote …
Redwoods Concert, Sun 9 March at 3pm
Enjoy the beauty of the Te Mata Park Redwoods and great music from New Zealand’s top original blues band, Riverhead
Slide, supported by Wyn Drabble. Bring your friends, a picnic and a rug to sit on for a very special concert in an
amazing setting. Gates open at 2pm – enter the Park from the end of Tauroa Road and access to the Redwoods is a gentle
20 minute walk. A shuttle bus will be available for those less physically able. Gates sales only – please bring cash (no
EFTPOS available).$10pp or $25 family of 4. Gates open 2.00pm. Enter from Tauroa Road.
ends