Egypt is using exceptional “Terrorism Circuit Courts” to target human rights defenders, silence dissent, and to lock up
activists during the COVID-19 pandemic, UN human rights experts* said today.
“Terrorism charges and exceptional courts are being used to target legitimate human rights activities, and have a
profound chilling effect on civil society as a whole,” the experts said. “The use of terrorism courts to target and
harass civil society is inconsistent with the rule of law.”
“We are particularly concerned that human rights defenders and civil society actors who have been charged with terrorism
are being detained during this pandemic as a form of de facto punishment, gravely endangering their right to life and
the right to be free from torture, inhuman and degrading treatment.”
The special courts, created at the end of 2013, appear to fundamentally infringe on individual rights and operate to
undermine the right to fair trial, the experts said.
They are part of a broader pattern of the use of terrorism and national security legislation and mechanisms as tools to
punish and silence legitimate criticism or expression in Egypt, the experts said.
“Despite the pretext of national security concerns, such targeting in fact undermines rather than advances both security
and human rights,” they said.
These courts violate many international human rights norms. Mass trials undermine the right to individual adjudication,
limit the right of access to lawyers and undermine the right of lawyers to engage in full and effective defence of their
clients. Trials taking place in the offices of the Ministry of the Interior subvert the right to openness and
transparency in the legal process.
“Defendants do not enjoy the right to confer safely and confidentially with their lawyer,” they said. “In addition, when
the accused are put on trial from behind glass or inside metal cages, sometimes cut off from proceedings at the
discretion of the presiding judge, they cannot effectively use their right to be present at their own trial. This
treatment also undermines the fundamental right of individuals to be presumed innocent until proven guilty.”
The sentencing in absentia of Bahey El-Din Hassan, well recognized human rights defender and director of the Cairo
Institute for Human Rights Studies, to 15 years in prison for his human rights activities including posting critical
Tweets, is shocking. It is an act of reprisal, seemingly punishing for his cooperation with the United Nations. The
exercise of free speech and human rights work are being treated as terrorism, and it appears that the Terrorism Circuit
Court is being used to retaliate against human rights activity protected by international law.
The experts said Egypt has a special duty to uphold human rights because this year it co-chairs the UN’s regular Global
Counter-Terrorism Strategy Review. The UN Global Counter-Terrorism Strategy requires that States apply their human
rights obligations when they engage in counter-terrorism.
“The symbolism is important,” the experts said. “It is vital that the State leading the Global Counter-Terrorism
Strategy Review uphold the highest standards of human rights protection domestically as it exhorts and demands that
other States do the same.”