IFJ Press Freedom in China Campaign Bulletin
December 8, 2009
To IFJ Asia-Pacific affiliates and friends,
Welcome to IFJ Asia-Pacific’s monthly Press Freedom in China Campaign e-bulletin. The next bulletin will be sent on January 8, 2010, and contributions are most welcome.
To contribute news or information, email ifjchina@ifj-asia.org. To visit the IFJ’s China Campaign page, go to
www.ifj.org.
Please distribute this bulletin widely among colleagues in the media.
In this bulletin:
1. One Year After Charter 08, Liu Still Detained
2. Cyber Dissident Sentenced to Three Years’ Jail
3. IFJ Calls on Obama to Discuss Media Freedom While in China
4. Media Restrictions and Regulations Multiply
5. Business Magazine Staff Quit Over Editorial Interference
6. Journalists Face Bribery Charges
7. Hong Kong’s Citizens’ Radio Penalised on Charges of Illegal Broadcasting
1. One Year After Charter 08, Liu Still Detained
A leader of the Charter 08 pro-democracy and political reform movement, Liu Xiaobo, remains in detention under charges
of “inciting subversion of state power” almost a year after the Charter 08 petition was delivered to China’s Government
on December 9, 2008. On November 23, the Beijing Security Bureau delayed Liu’s scheduled court hearing for an
undetermined period and without explanation. It was the third postponement since he was charged on June 23. The
petition, which was timed to coincide with the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, has
gathered more than 10,000 signatures in the past year. The Charter calls on China’s Government to promote and foster a
democratic society, defend human rights and uphold freedom of expression – civil values already enshrined in China’s
Constitution. Leading Charter activists and prominent signatories have reported being interrogated by authorities after
information about the Charter reform proposals were formally made public.
2. Cyber Dissident Sentenced to Three Years’ Jail
Cyber dissident and co-founder of the 64 Tianwang website (www.64tianwang.com) Huang Qi was sentenced to three years’
imprisonment by the Court of Wuhou in Sichuan Province in November for posting articles related to the 2008 Sichuan
earthquake. Huang, 46, was detained in June 2008 after posting an article online which criticised the Government’s
handling of the earthquake disaster in May 2008. The judgement stated that Huang was guilty of “illegal possession of
state secrets” because he had obtained three documents which allegedly contained confidential “state secrets”. According
to Huang’s wife, Zeng Li, the documents to which the judgement referred were publicly available on local government
websites. She also reported that two elderly supporters were assaulted by unidentified people outside the court as the
sentence was handed down, while others were prevented from observing the proceedings. The IFJ has called for Huang’s
immediate unconditional release.
3. IFJ Calls on Obama to Discuss Media Freedom While in China
As United States President Barack Obama made an official visit to Beijing, China on November 16, the IFJ called on him
to use the opportunity to highlight his concerns for press freedom during his discussions with Chinese government
officials. In an open letter, the IFJ reminded Obama of the failure of China’s Government to uphold its promise before
the 2008 Beijing Olympics to allow greater freedom of expression and the press. The letter further noted Chinese
President Hu Jintao’s repeated public statements that China would uphold the right of people in China to freedom of the
press and freedom of expression. However, journalists in China have contended with more than 200 orders and restrictions
by the Central and Provincial Propaganda banning sensitive content since the beginning of 2009. Many journalists and
writers including Liu Xiaobo, Huang Qi, Shi Tao, Sun Lin, Hu Jia and Tan Zuoran are in jail for the content of their
writings. In his World Press Freedom Day speech on May 1 2009, Obama said the imprisonment of Chinese human rights
activist and writer Hu Jia (sentenced to 3.5 years jail in April 2008 for inciting subversion of state power), was of
the “emblematic examples” of the deterioration of press freedom worldwide.
4. Media Restrictions and Regulations Multiply
A nationwide order for all media to run reports issued by the government news agency Xinhua was imposed by China’s
authorities during US President Obama’s visit to China in November. The order covered any news reports or articles about
questions asked at an interactive forum with Obama at the Shanghai Science Technology Museum. People were forbidden from
organising for questions to be relayed over the internet and voiced during the event. The IFJ also understands that
Guangzhou Cable TV network intercepted the broadcasting signal of Hong Kong’s English language Asia Television channel
while Obama was answering a question about restrictions on the internet in China. The department also ordered that any
media reports about protests or spontaneous news during Obama’s visit were not to be published. The November 13
detention in Beijing of Zhao Lianhai, a representative of a group of parents whose children suffered illness or death
during China’s “tainted milk” contamination scandal in 2008, was not reported in local media due to the media blackout.
5. Magazine Staff Quit Over Editorial Interference
China’s Caijing business magazine faces concerns over editorial integrity and managerial interference after the resignation of the
publications editor-in-chief, Hu Shuli, on November 9. Hu joins more than 200 staff from the magazine’s marketing and
editorial departments who have resigned in protest at reports that Caijing’s board tried to influence the editorial team. It is claimed the board was pressured by the magazine’s parent company, the
Stock Exchange Executive Council, and other government-controlled groups. Nine executives and general manager Wu
Chuanhui are among the list. Pressure on Caijing reportedly intensified after Hu sent three journalists to cover ethnic-based riots in Urumqi, the capital of China’s
Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, in early July, despite Central Propaganda Department orders banning journalists in
the area. Articles published in the magazine about a new wave of violence in Xinjiang in September used
government-provided information.
6. Journalists Face Bribery Charges
The IFJ called for fair and open trial proceedings for 10 journalists charged with accepting bribes in order not to
report on a mining accident in Lijiawa Yu Xian County, Hubei, on July 14, 2008. According to a November 30 report in the
State-owned China Daily, the Central Government also reportedly charged 48 officials, including the mine owners, the county chief, work safety
officials and police officers in connection with an alleged cover-up. A BBC report at the time of the disaster said
officials had allegedly moved bodies, destroyed evidence and bribed journalists to hush up the accident. One rescuer and
34 miners were killed in the accident, which occurred shortly before China was to host the Olympic Games in Beijing in
August 2008.
7. Hong Kong’s Citizens’ Radio Penalised on Charges of Illegal Broadcasting
A November 9 retrial of 14 illegal broadcasting charges against Citizens' Radio of Hong Kong delivered a guilty verdict
and ordered six staff - including the station manager Tsang Kin-shing, Hong Kong legislator Leung Kwok-hung and radio
station operator Oceans Technology company representative Lo Chau - to pay fines from about US 385 to US 1538.
Magistrate Douglas Yau Tak-ong reportedly said attempts by Citizens’ Radio staff to continue broadcasting without a
licence in an attempt to campaign for greater diversity of radio outlets in Hong Kong were “noble”. On January 8, 2008,
the same magistrate dismissed all charges against Citizens’ Radio on the basis that Hong Kong’s broadcasting licence
system was unconstitutional. However, Hong Kong’s Government challenged the decision in the Court of Appeal, which ruled
that the constitutionality of the licensing regime was not a necessary component of the offence of unlicensed
broadcasting. Citizens’ Radio, which began in 2006, had previously applied to the Broadcasting Authority for a licence
but was rejected.
ENDS