CEPR Adds Up Available Recount Data, Finds Significant Vote Reduction for Calderon
Result Could Explain Electoral Authorities' Reluctance to Release Recount Data
For Immediate Release: September 2, 2006
WASHINGTON - The Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR) has found a significant loss of votes for PAN
presidential candidate Felipe Calderón in a sample of recounted ballots.
Adding up the numbers for 1,706 ballot boxes (casillas) shows a loss of 1,362 votes for Felipe Calderón. Andrés Manuel
López Obrador of the PBT shows a gain of 77 votes.
"This is inexplicably one-sided, with Calderón losing votes but López Obrador not losing any," said CEPR Co-Director
Mark Weisbrot. "It is also a significant percentage of votes in an election this close."
The 1,362 votes lost by Calderón represent 0.54 percent of his votes in these ballot boxes.
The result for the whole group of recounted ballot boxes would likely show a similar percentage, since the above ballot
box totals were chosen randomly from the documents posted on the Electoral Tribunal of the Federal Judiciary (TEPJF) web
site. The ballot box totals compiled by CEPR comprise 14.4 percent of the 11,839 ballot boxes that were recounted.
The Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR) has been searching through many thousands of pages in 375 documents
[www.trife.org.mx (see "Ãƒltimas sentencias dictadas")] released over the past week by the TEPJF, for numbers on the
recount conducted by the TEPJF from August 9 to August 13. The process is laborious but most of the results appear to be
buried in these documents.
In other words, the full recount results might be available but it takes several days of research to find and compile
the numbers for 11,839 ballot boxes scattered among many thousands of pages of documents.
Although the recount was completed nearly three weeks ago, the TEPJF has refused to release the numbers showing how the
candidates' vote totals were changed by the recount. This contrasts sharply to the procedure followed for the
preliminary and second vote tallies in July, when the results were made public immediately.
"This certainly casts doubt on the electoral authorities' decision to reject a full recount," said Weisbrot. "And it
makes the TEPJF's decision not to release the recounted vote totals look even worse."*
See also CEPR's most recent paper examining the "adding up" errors in the vote count: http://www.cepr.net/publications/
*Last Monday the TEPJF released the results of its annulment of 237,736 votes; many press accounts mistakenly reported
these numbers as the results of the recount, which they were not. The ballot boxes where votes were annulled are not the
same as those which were recounted. See http:// www.trife.org.mx/consultas/boletines/archivos/079-2006.html.
The Center for Economic and Policy Research is an independent, nonpartisan think tank that was established to promote
democratic debate on the most important economic and social issues that affect people's lives. CEPR's Advisory Board of
Economists includes Nobel Laureate economists Robert Solow and Joseph Stiglitz; Richard Freeman, Professor of Economics
at Harvard University; and Eileen Appelbaum, Professor and Director of the Center for Women and Work at Rutgers