Mar del Plata: Moving Beyond the Headlines
Ambassador John Maisto, U.S. Permanent Representative to OAS and U.S. National
Coordinator for Summit of the Americas
Remarks to the George Washington University panel: "The Mar del Plata Summit:
Results and Challenges Ahead"
November 16, 2005
If you believe that Summits are events where, periodically, the Hemisphere's democratic leaders meet to discuss and
yes, debate, issues of importance to their people, Mar del Plata was a timely, and much needed Summit.
This Summit was lively, and it was controversial, as reported in the media, and as those of us who were there can
attest. President Lagos said it the best: "Fue un debate como pocas veces se ha visto."
But, at the end of the day, the leaders issued a 76-paragraph declaration which showed unity and consensus on a wide
range of issues, including a reaffirmation of representative democracy, the need for sound economic policies, the need
to deal with poverty and how; eradicating the worst forms of child labor, and fighting terrorism and narcotics. And it
issued an action plan, and 5 declarations about specific issues.
So, the United States judges Mar del Plata to be a success. Here's why:
Going into the Summit, the United States had three primary objectives:
First, we wanted to reaffirm the importance of strong democratic institutions, which deliver opportunities, both social
and economic, for people to improve their lives. That covers the gamut of poverty and job creation. The Summits of the
Americas is a gathering of leaders who are committed to the full and effective exercise of representative democracy, as
expressed in the OAS Charter and the Inter-American Democratic Charter, and was reaffirmed. Representative democracy is
the one indispensable requirement for countries' participation in the Summit process. However, several countries which
did join us at the Summit are currently experiencing challenges to their fragile democratic institutions. The assembled
leaders sought to call attention to how the international community, and especially the OAS by means of the
Inter-American Democratic Charter and under our new Secretary General, who is here today, could support those
Second, we wanted to emphasize the important connection between sound economic policies, growth, job creation, and
poverty reduction. This is what we have heard today by all of our other presenters. This involves a vibrant private
sector, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), as the motor of job creation. We sought to reaffirm our
commitment to the Monterrey Consensus, which states that developing countries have primary responsibility for their own
development, and the international community will support those countries that have sound policies, good governance, and
the rule of law. And finally, we view trade liberalization, bilaterally, regionally, and globally, as one of the best
ways to attract investment, create opportunities, and lift millions out of poverty.
Third, the United States wanted to contribute to a successful Summit process, building on the accomplishments at the
2001 Quebec Summit and last year's Special Summit in Nuevo Leon (2004). These past Summits made significant
contributions to our hemispheric dialogue. In Quebec, the Heads of State asked foreign ministers to draft the
Inter-American Democratic Charter. In Nuevo Leon, leaders agreed to concentrate on measurable, time-bound initiatives to
promote sound economic policies that have a direct impact on people's lives, such as halving the cost of sending
remittances by 2008, or tripling IDB lending to SMEs by 2007. At Mar del Plata, we hoped to build upon these efforts of
past Summits, by having our democratic leaders commit to initiatives that create jobs, foster upward mobility, and
strengthen democratic governance.
So what were the results of Mar del Plata? If you look only at the headlines, you might think the Summit ended in
complete disarray, without agreement on a mutually-beneficial hemispheric agenda. However, if you read a little more or
the Argentine press on Sunday, Nov. 6, the day after the Summit, and I commend the Argentine press for their work you
will discover there was a lot more to this Summit.
First, all but one country reaffirmed that representative democracy, as enshrined in the OAS Charter, is an
indispensable condition for the peace, development, and stability of the region. As the first line of the Declaration of
Mar del Plata demonstrates, we are committed to more than just democratic elections in this Hemisphere.
Democratically-elected leaders must also govern democratically, according to the principles of the OAS Charter and the
Inter-American Democratic Charter. The Hemisphere's leaders committed explicitly to the full and effective application
of the Inter-American Democratic Charter, which states that "the peoples of the Americas have a right to democracy and
their governments have an obligation to promote and defend it". To address special areas of concern in our Hemisphere,
the leaders issued communiqués to deal with threats to democracy and security in Haiti, Nicaragua, Bolivia, and
Colombia. We all look forward to working with the Secretary General to continue and build upon the good work that the
OAS is doing to strengthen democratic governance in our Hemisphere.
To keep our societies free and create an environment where all our citizens can prosper, the leaders reaffirmed their
commitment, strongly, against corruption, terrorism, and narco-trafficking. To focus on the poorest and most vulnerable
of our citizens, the leaders also stressed the importance of fighting discrimination, providing better opportunities for
women and vulnerable groups, and promoting social inclusion.
Our second priority at this Summit was also accomplished: we left no questions about the important relationship between
sound macro-economic policies, growth, job creation, and poverty reduction. It is all up there at the front of the
Declaration. The leaders stress the important role of the business sector as the engine for job creation, and devote an
entire chapter of the Declaration to the role of micro, small and medium-size enterprises. The Monterrey Consensus is
reaffirmed as the fundamental basis for our partnership for development.
This Hemisphere also clearly came out in favor of trade liberalization as a path to prosperity. The leaders discussed
an ambitious agenda for the Doha Round in the political Declaration, including the issue of special and differential
treatment related to small economies. We agree with the Hemisphere that the agricultural negotiations will unlock the
full potential of the Doha Round. That is why the Hemisphere's leaders sent a strong, direct, focused message to the
Doha round in Hong Kong to substantially reduce agricultural tariffs and trade-distorting subsidies. This is a message
President Bush highlighted at the UN High Level Event on September 14, emphasized again with President Lula just after
the Summit, and that he reiterated just this week on his route to Asia to attend the APEC summit.
Furthermore, 33 countries reaffirmed the importance of moving forward with trade liberalization in this Hemisphere. 29
countries, which represent over 90% of the GDP of this Hemisphere, reaffirmed their commitment to a prompt conclusion to
the FTAA negotiations. The four Mercosur countries believed that the conditions are not ripe right now for the FTAA, but
agreed to re-examine the situation after the Hong Kong trade meetings. There was debate and no consensus about the next
steps forward but 33 countries firmly supported trade liberalization as a path to better lives for our citizens. We will
continue to emphasize the importance of the FTAA. However, if you look beyond the headlines, the FTAA was only 1
paragraph of 76 in the Declaration. Our leaders were not at the Summit of the Americas to negotiate trade.
For all these reasons, we do view Mar del Plata as a successful contribution to the Summit process. There was a healthy
debate among our leaders about the theme of this Summit, "Creating Jobs to Fight Poverty and Strengthen Democratic
Governance." This theme of employment is of utmost importance, confirmed in poll after poll, to all of our Hemisphere's
The Plan of Action did not have quite as many concrete time-bound initiatives as we would have liked. However, the
Hemisphere welcomed many of our concrete proposals, including:
* An Infrastructure Facility of the Americas, a new institution to assess the feasibility of infrastructure project
proposals from private and public sponsors. * The creation of five Opportunity Zones, which will encourage new business
opportunities, particularly for disadvantaged citizens. * A $16 million contribution to continue and expand our fight
against the worst forms of child labor. * The development of more efficient energy sources and cleaner technologies. *
Strengthening the Global Fund to expand our fight against HIV/AIDS in the Hemisphere, and to keep ahead of the curve. *
Effective implementation of the Declaration of Florida on "Delivering the Benefits of Democracy" which enhances the
ability of Secretary General Insulza to address threats to democracy in the region, specifically strengthening the
application of the Inter-American Democratic Charter.
The Journey Forward
So how do we move forward after Mar del Plata? We don't need to invent anything new or magical in the Summit process.
There are no panaceas or huge new pots of money. If we want to create jobs, the elements are all there. The Hemisphere's
presidents and prime ministers must exercise the leadership and the political will needed to make the hard choices and
the necessary structural adjustments and institutional reforms. We need good economic and labor policies, and clear,
transparent, rules of the game to attract investment. (In that respect, I'd like to point out that the U.S. and Uruguay
signed a bilateral investment treaty at the Summit.)
The private sector served notice in their pre-Mar del Plata meeting of how it is anxious to play its role in job
creation. In the coming years, we will need to continue to engage with our hemispheric partners to reinforce the
elements necessary for creating jobs, fighting poverty, and bolstering democratic governance.
We will need to continue to follow up on previous Summit mandates from Nuevo Leon and Quebec, as well as the
initiatives from the Mar del Plata Summit. We welcome the work of the OAS Summits Secretariat, and especially their
recent reports on commitments made at previous Summits. The help of civil society and the private sector in monitoring
implementation of Summit mandates has been and will continue to be invaluable over the next few years, to hold our
leaders accountable to their words.
And we look forward to the long journey from Mar del Plata to Trinidad and Tobago or Colombia, where the Fifth Summit
of the Americas will be held.
Over the next years, the Summit of the Americas process will probably receive very few headlines. But our elected
governments, working with civil society and the private sector, will continue to toil daily to deliver the lesser-known
benefits of the Mar del Plata Summit to all our Hemisphere's citizens.
Now, just how the Mar del Plata Summit will be judged is yet to be determined. But what the elected governments do to
carry out their commitments, and their challenge, beyond the headlines, will continue to be as it has been since Summits
began as expressed in what our friends from Nike sum up so well: JUST DO IT.
Released on November 16, 2005