Amnesty International Report 2005: A Dangerous New Agenda
Governments are betraying their promise of a world order based on human rights said Amnesty International today as it
launched its annual report documenting human rights issues of concern to AI during 2004 and AI’s activities during the
year.
Governments had failed to show principled leadership and must be held to account, said Ced Simpson, Executive Director
of Amnesty International New Zealand.
"A new agenda is in the making with the language of freedom and justice being used to pursue policies creating fear and
insecurity, including cynical attempts to redefine and sanitize torture," said Mr Simpson.
This new agenda, combined with the indifference and paralysis of the international community, failed countless thousands
of people in humanitarian crises and forgotten conflicts throughout 2004.
In Darfur, the Sudanese government generated a human rights catastrophe and the international community did too little
too late to address the crisis, betraying hundreds of thousands of people.
In Haiti, individuals responsible for serious human rights violations were allowed to regain positions of power. In the
eastern Democratic Republic of Congo there was no effective response to the systematic rape of tens of thousands of
women, children and even babies. Despite the holding of elections, Afghanistan slipped into a downward spiral of
lawlessness and instability. Violence was endemic in Iraq.
At a national level governments betrayed human rights at terrible cost to ordinary people. Russian soldiers reportedly
tortured, raped and sexually abused Chechen women with impunity. Zimbabwe’s government manipulated food shortages for
political reasons.
The betrayal of human rights by governments was accompanied by increasingly horrific acts of terrorism as armed groups
stooped to new levels of brutality.
"The televised beheading of captives in Iraq, the taking of over a thousand people hostage including hundreds of
children in a school in Beslan and the massacre of hundreds of commuters in Madrid shocked the world. Yet governments
are failing to confront their lack of success in addressing terrorism, persisting with failed but politically-convenient
strategies. Four years after 9/11, the promise to make the world a safer place remains hollow," said Mr. Simpson
The US administration’s attempts to dilute the absolute ban on torture through new policies and quasi-management speak
such as "environmental manipulation", "stress positions" and "sensory manipulation", was one of the most damaging
assaults on global values.
Despite the US administration’s repeated use of the language of justice and freedom there was a huge gap between
rhetoric and reality. This was starkly illustrated by the failure to conduct a full and independent investigation into
the appalling torture and ill-treatment of detainees by US soldiers in Iraq’s Abu Ghraib prison and the failure to hold
senior individuals to account.
Many governments showed a shocking contempt for the rule of law. Nigeria granted Charles Taylor, former President of
Liberia, refugee status despite his indictment for killings, mutilations and rape. Israel’s construction of a barrier
inside the occupied West Bank ignored the International Court of Justice opinion that this violated international human
rights and humanitarian law. Arbitrary detentions and unfair trials took place under security legislation in a number of
countries.
There were also signs of hope in 2004 said Mr. Simpson.
Legal challenges to the new agenda included US Supreme Court judgements on Guantánamo detainees, the ruling by the UK
Law Lords on indefinite detention without charge or trial of "terrorist suspects", and the bail granted by New Zealand‘s
Supreme Court of Ahmed Zaoui.
Public pressure included the spontaneous turnout of millions of people in Spain protesting against the Madrid bombings,
popular uprisings in Georgia and Ukraine and the growing debate on political change in the Middle East.
"Increasingly, the duplicity of governments and the brutality of armed groups are being challenged - by judicial
decisions, popular resistance, public pressure and UN reform initiatives. The challenge for the human rights movement is
to harness the power of civil society and push governments to deliver on their human rights promises," said Ced Simpson.
For a full copy of the Amnesty International Report 2005: the state of the world's human rights please go to: http://www.amnesty.org.nz