GUSH SHALOM
[] "We won't know peace, as long as our neighbors do not" [] The refusal epidemic continues to spread: For the first
time, a regular service officer refuses service in OT
"We won't know peace, as long as our neighbors do not"
[In the following Uri Avnery takes position against those who regard strife among Palestinians as something to be happy
about, and clarifies why disintegration of the PA structure and the leadership of Arafat won't bring peace any closer.]
Hebrew at request & soon at the site òáøéú òì ôé á÷ùä àå á÷øåá áàúø
I am writing this with an aching heart. I have postponed writing it as long as I could. In Jewish tradition, there is a
searing phrase: "The Temple was not destroyed but for gratuitous hatred." It sums up the events in beleaguered
Jerusalem, in the year 70 AD, when the town was surrounded by the Roman legions. While Titus' soldiers were maintaining
the siege and the population was beginning to starve, inside the town ferocious battles took place between various
factions of zealots, who killed each other and burnt each other's last stores of wheat.
Something like this is now taking place in the Palestinian territories. While the occupation forces are tightening the
siege and carrying out "targeted killings", battles between the Palestinians themselves have broken out, with militants
shooting at each other, targeting leaders and burning headquarters. Occupation generals, politicians and commentators in
Israel follow the events with glee or click their tongues sanctimoniously: "Didn't we tell you? The Palestinians can't
rule themselves, there is no one to talk with, we have no partner for peace. When they are left to themselves, anarchy
reigns." On many Israeli tongues the Greek word "chaos" (pronounced with an American accent) was rolling.
Since the Sharon government is responsible for the present situation in Gaza in the first place, it resembles the son
who kills both his parents and pleads in court: "Have mercy! I am an orphan!" Paradoxically, the Palestinian factions,
of all people, seem to believe Sharon's announcement about his intention to leave Gaza. What is happening there is,
first of all, a fight about the skin of the bear that has not yet been caught.
Everybody talks about "reforms", a word dear to the Americans, but the battle is about power and control. Muhammad
Dahlan's faction hopes to take possession of the Gaza Strip before Sharon's promised withdrawal. Sharon's people are
open about their preference for this group. The Americans support them in order to suit Sharon, and the Egyptians
support them to please the Americans. The rival faction supports Mussa Arafat who was sent by his relative, Yasser
Arafat, to control the security apparatus. He may not be the most popular appointee, but the leader in far-away Ramallah
appointed his most trusted lieutenant in order to fend off the danger he fears most: that the Gaza Strip will cut itself
off from the West Bank and become a kind of autonomous Bantustan under Israeli-American-Egyptian tutelage.
This is what is happening on the surface. But the events also have deeper roots in the present Palestinian situation,
which consists of an existential contradiction. On the one side, the Palestinian war of liberation is far from over. It
is at its height. It can well be said that never has the very existence of the Palestinians - both as a nation and as
individuals - been in greater danger than now.
On the other hand, on the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip there has come into being a kind of mini-state that requires
a state-like administration: security, economy, education, justice, welfare and so on.
The surreal situation in Gaza reflects this contradiction: while Mussa Arafat, Muhammad Dahlan and the other Fatah
leaders fight each other for control of the Palestinian Authority and its security organs, a brutal war is going on
between the occupation forces and the Tanzim, Hamas and Jihad militants.
The leader of the Palestinian war of liberation is Yasser Arafat. Among the Palestinians, no one contests that. He is
the only person able to safeguard the unity of the Palestinian people. He is the only leader with a wide strategic grasp
of all the geographic and functional aspects of the dispersed Palestinian people. He has the attributes necessary for a
leader in such a situation: an uncontested personal authority, physical courage, the ability to make decisions and a
talent for manoeuver. Palestinians call him the 'Father of the Nation" and compare him with George Washington, David
Ben-Gurion and Nelson Mandela.
The criticism of Arafat, prevalent mostly among the intellectual and political elite - concerns his functioning as the
chief of the "mini- state". Unlike the Prime Minister of Israel, Arafat is not suspected of personal corruption. He is
being blamed for the fact that the Palestinian Authority is too much like the other Arab regimes, suffering from
concentration of power, proliferation of security apparatuses, corruption, cronyism and the undue influence of big
families.
As a Palestinian member of parliament told me recently: "Arafat leads the national struggle, and all of us support him.
But he neglects the domestic order, and against that we protest."
However, Sharon is not fighting against Arafat to encourage him to delegate power or because he has seven different
security formations (the United States has 15 intelligence agencies, four military services and an untold number of
police organizations.) He is fighting against Arafat because his elimination will cause the disintegration of the
Palestinian nation into splinters and thus clear the way for ethnic cleansing. Arafat is very much aware of this danger
and, in comparison, all the diseases of the Palestinian Authority seem to him secondary.
The strategy of Sharon and his generals is simple and brutal: to destroy the Palestinian Authority, turn life in the
occupied territories into hell, disintegrate Palestinian society and drive the survivors from the country, not in one
dramatic sweep (as in 1948) but in a slow, continuous, creeping process. Up to now, this has not succeeded. In spite of
inhuman conditions, the Palestinian society has held on in a manner that arouses wonderment. The events of the last few
weeks look to Sharon and the army chiefs like signs of collapse. I believe they are wrong and that the Palestinian
society will draw back from the abyss.
It is reasonable to expect that the prisoner in the Mukata'ah, who has already led his people out from so many
existential crises, will do so again. I sincerely hope so, because Arafat is the only person who can make peace with us.
We will know no peace, as long as our neighbors do not.
[] The refusal epidemic continues to spread: For the first time, a regular service officer refuses service in the
Territories
Translated from an article by Osnat Shustak, Ma'ariv 21/7/2004 - not found in the web version.
Second Lieutenant T. a 28-year battalion doctor and regular officer, refused to join his armoured battalion in an
incursion into the Gaza Strip - for reasons of conscience. Several weeks ago, battalion 82 of the Seventh Regiment was
sent on operation at the town of Beit Hanoun in the northern Gaza Strip, aimed at preventing the launch of Quasam
rockets at the [Israeli town of] Sderot. T. had previously served in the Territories, and even took part this May in
"Operation Rainbow" [including the demolition of houses and the shooting of tank shells at unarmed demonstrators] at the
town of Rafah - though already then he expressed reservations about the army's activities in the Gaza Strip. This time
he refused to take part in the operation, stating that taking part in the army's actions in the Territories would
contradict the hippocratic oath he swore as a doctor, as well as standing in contrast to the army's own declared values
and being detrimental to the state security. Many efforts were made to convince him to recant, but T. stuck to his
refusal. Of no avail were the exhortations of his commanding officers, who stated that his job would be to take care of
Palestinians as well as fellow soldiers, and that by refusing to join the operation he is putting soldiers' lives in
danger. Finding him insistent, T.'s direct commander passed him on to the Seventh Regiment commander, who sentenced T.
to 35 days' imprisonment for refusing an order during a military operation. He also told T.: "You are not worthy to be
an officer". It seems that upon being released from his prison term T. will be discharged from service - though the army
had paid for his medical studies in the expectation of getting years of service in return.
"I regard this very gravely" said Defence Minister Mofaz on Army Radio."There are two highly detrimental aspects to this
officer's actions. First, he refused to take part in an action very vit al to the security of Israel's citizens, in
order to prevent the shooting of rockets at Sderot and its environs. Also, this officer who is a doctor was unwilling to
help soldiers who might be hurt, which is trampling upon the hippocratic oath. I think that the way his commanders dealt
with this case is the way to deal with refusers."
On the other hand, David Zonshein of the "Courage to Refuse" movement praised the doctor's action: "It is not 'an
extremist act', it is a very Zionist act. It is important for the public to know that there are officers who want to
serve and love their country, but are opposed to the enormous damage which service in the country is doing to the
country. This is the first time that a regular service officer is refusing service in the Territories. I hope and
believe that his act h as broken a fissure in the consensus and that more officers will now be willing to act for what
they believe in - even if they have to pay a personal price".
[N.B. Ma'ariv did not mention to its readers that the Beit Hanoun operation in which Dr. T. refused to take part was
about a still ongoing campaign of destruction of Palestinian fields, hothouses and orange groves, demolition of houses
and the imposition of a weeks-long siege on Beit Hanoun's 20,000 inhabitants. ]
# Truth against Truth - opposite views on the history of the conflict in 101 steps
Hebrew / òáøéú http://www.gush-shalom.org/Docs/Truth_Heb.pdf