INDEPENDENT NEWS

Greens co-chair accused of “abysmal ignorance”

Published: Mon 7 May 2007 02:05 PM
7 May 2007
Greens co-chair accused of “abysmal ignorance” about modern electricity generation
Any organization such as the Green Party claiming that man-made global warming is the biggest threat to the world should support nuclear power. This has been said today by Bryan Leyland, an energy consultant of Auckland, who is chair of the economic panel of the New Zealand Climate Science Coalition.
He was responding to a statement over the weekend by Russel Norman, co-chair of the Greens about renewable energy sources.
“Russel Norman's ‘let's go renewable not nuclear’ reveals his abysmal ignorance of electricity system and recent developments in nuclear power generation. I conclude that Russel and his Green party have ulterior motives of continuing to oppose it,” said Mr Leyland.
“Nuclear power provides 17% of the world electricity. On the basis of deaths per unit of energy output, the evidence shows that it is, by far, the world's safest and least environmentally damaging form of large scale power generation. Over last 50 years, dam failures have killed thousands of people and coal fired power generation has resulted in millions of deaths from mining accidents and air pollution. The UN report on Chernobyl says that fewer than 50 people died as a result of radiation from the accident. The radiation after the core meltdown at Three Mile Island was less than is emitted by the granite structure of Grand Central Station in New York .
“To argue against nuclear power on the basis of Chernobyl, is the same as arguing against modern ocean liners because the Titanic did not carry enough to life boats and did not have radar. “
Mr Leyland said that the problem of disposal of radioactive wastes has been solved. Deep burial in sealed containers has been accepted in Finland, Sweden, Russia, France, United Kingdom and the United States.
“It is easy to decommission a nuclear power station. No one, to my knowledge, knows how to decommission a large dam.
“Modern nuclear power stations do not produce anything that can be easily used to make nuclear weapons. If nuclear power generation changes from uranium to thorium, the problem is eliminated entirely.
“If the Green Party really care about nuclear proliferation, they should strongly support the joint Russian/US efforts to build nuclear reactors that can generate power from the 200-plus tonnes of surplus weapons grade plutonium that continue to be a prime terrorist target.
“If Al Quaeda - or anyone else - wanted to paralyse New Zealand's electricity system there are much easier and effective ways of doing it than attacking a nuclear power station. It is much easier - and more effective - to destroy a chain of hydro power stations than a nuclear station.”
Mr Leyland said that "pebble bed" reactors, which are one very promising candidate for nuclear power generation in New Zealand, cannot meltdown, produce waste that cannot be reprocessed (for weapons or anything else) and come in unit sizes between 200 and 400 MW. They are expected to produce base load electricity for less than 8 c/kWh. If the cost of the backup stations needed when the wind doesn't blow are included, New Zealanders would pay much more than that for power from wind farms.
ENDS

Next in Business, Science, and Tech

Crown to seek clarity through appeal of High Court decision
By: New Zealand Government
Better safeguards for Commercial Video On-Demand viewers
By: New Zealand Government
Inland Revenue and ACC calling ‘time’ on cheques.
By: Inland Revenue Department
Growing New Zealand’s Capital Markets 2029
By: Baldwin Boyle Group
Aalls for more funding to stop plague of wallabies
By: Forest And Bird
COMMENT: Retail shareholder perspective missing from review
By: BusinessDesk
Regulators and NZSA welcome capital markets recommendations
By: BusinessDesk
Change tax regime for KiwiSaver, capital markets review
By: BusinessDesk
Government welcomes Capital Markets 2029 Report
By: New Zealand Government
Time for a frank discussion about capital markets
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media