INDEPENDENT NEWS

More From ALRANZ On SPUC And Christian Heritage

Published: Thu 23 Dec 1999 10:03 AM
The Christian Heritage Party has joined Christchurch SPUC in making ignorant statements about the current proposed constructive changes to our abortion laws.
It is difficult to see how antiabortion women would be disadvantaged under the Code of Health and Disability Consumers Rights. This requires practitioner disclosure of identity and affiliation and protects consumers from harassment. I hope Mr.Capill is willing to extend the same rights to pro-choice women when it comes to anti-abortion doctors.
In 1982, Wall v Livingstone prohibited third party interference with women's confidential medical records in the context of abortion decisions. It has no factual basis for its claim that mental health grounds are being used illegitimately. Reactive depression is one possible legitimate clinical ground that could be used in this context.
Christian Heritage also refers to the Ministry of Health booklet on abortion. ALRANZ made four Official Information Act requests to the Ministry of Health and Abortion Supervisory Committee on this matter. Neither organisation records formal clinical consultation, pre-release testing, trial release, or other orthodox specifications for Ministry health education resources. We urge the new coalition government to drop this travesty of an informed consent resource.
Finally, Christian Heritage demonstrates ignorance of current interpretations of our existing law. Wall Livingston found that there was no statutory entity called "the unborn child" in New Zealand statute and case law. There is no legal obligation to any such illusory being.
ends

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on the Royal Commission into child abuse
By: Gordon Campbell
Cases delays: court staff refuse to handle sentencing papers
By: RNZ
Primary school teachers on strike again today
By: RNZ
Scholtens inquiry released
By: New Zealand Government
Prison reform group wants debate on prisoners' right to vote
By: RNZ
Jami-Lee Ross Temporary Delegate for Electors of Botany
By: New Zealand First Party
Do you know what data is being collected about you?
By: Maori Council
PM's Post-Cab 12/11/18: Abuse And Neglect Inquiry Expanded
By: The Scoop Team
Abuse survivors encouraged to speak as inquiry scope widens
By: RNZ
Terms of Reference set for Inquiry into Abuse in Care
By: Department Of Internal Affairs
Royal Commission of Inquiry scope expanded
By: New Zealand Government
Anglicans welcome a broader inquiry
By: Anglican Church in Aotearoa
Maori Council welcomes Dr Erueti’s appointment
By: Maori Council
Ongoing court strikes could lead to miscarriage of justice
By: RNZ
Judges Vigilant to Impact of Pay Dispute
By: Chief District Court Judge Jan-Marie Doogue
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media