21 April 2017
E tū: proposed Equal Pay bill is not justice for women
E tū says the equal pay settlement announced this week may be the last unless the government changes its draft bill
related to future equal pay claims.
E tū took the equal pay case on behalf of Kristine Bartlett, which this week culminated in a $2 billion settlement offer
for care and support workers in Aged Care, Disability Services, and Home Support.
E tū’s Assistant National Secretary, John Ryall says if the bill is not changed, women would face too many hurdles to
achieve equal pay.
He says the problem is Section 23 of the draft bill, related to identifying suitable comparators i.e. wages earned by
men who perform work with similar experience, skills, and responsibility.
“It does that by forcing women, through their unions, to firstly identify appropriate male comparators in their
employer’s business; then similar businesses to their employer; then the same sector or industry, and only then can they
use comparators from outside their industry.
“This is obviously intended to hugely slow down equal pay claims.
“In the care and support negotiations, the Government and the unions did not agree on any single comparator, but did
take several comparators into account during negotiations.
“If we had been forced to go through the hierarchy of comparators as set out in this draft bill then we would never have
reached a settlement.”
John says the bill needs to be rewritten to reflect the Report of the Joint Working Party on Pay Equity as well as the
Court of Appeal’s approach to comparators in the Terranova case.
He warns the government will feel the wrath of New Zealand women if the bill hobbles their ability to win fair pay.
“Women across the country are celebrating this week’s equal pay settlement. They will be furious if the government
doesn’t get this right.”
E tū: the new union for New Zealanders
E tū has been created by the merger of the Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union and Service and Food Workers'
E tū represents more than 50,000 working New Zealanders in industries as diverse as aviation, construction, journalism,
food manufacturing, mining and cleaning.
By standing together in a union workers get higher wages and better conditions. As the country's largest private sector
union E tū can provide members with workplace representation, legal advice, a freephone support centre, work rights
education and broad representation through E tū's campaigning and research work.
We campaign hard for workers' rights, health and safety, a living wage for all Kiwis, and recognising high-value