1 September 2015
Media release
NZ names four alternative flags for referendum ranking
The Flag Consideration Panel announced today the four flag designs that eligible voters will rank in the first binding
postal referendum this year, between 20 November and 11 December.
The four designs are:
• ‘Silver Fern (Black & White)’, designed by Alofi Kanter from Auckland
• ‘Silver Fern (Red, White and Blue)’, designed by Kyle Lockwood, originally from Wellington
• ‘Koru’, designed by Andrew Fyfe from Wellington
• ‘Silver Fern (Black, White and Blue)’, also designed by Kyle Lockwood.
Flag Consideration Panel chair, Professor John Burrows, said the Panel’s decision had been guided first and foremost by
the results of its engagement programme across a range of communities where thousands of Kiwis shared what was special
about New Zealand, as well as the Panel’s own selection criteria. He stressed the importance of designs being
unmistakeably from New Zealand, timeless, free of any copyright or intellectual property issues and with the ability to
work in a variety of contexts.
“Interestingly, reviewing the flag designs long listed in detail and in real-life contexts helped shape the Panel’s
decision making. For example, there are practical matters such as how they look from a long distance, how they look from
both sides, when flying (or still), in situations where they may hang vertically, and so on.
It would have also been easy to take a category based approach to our selection, for example have a silver fern option,
a Southern Cross option, a koru option and an abstract or kiwi option. However, our mandate was to select what we
believe to be the strongest flag designs, with the best symbol and colour combination that work well in any context from
celebration to commemoration.
We have made the decision to include one of the designs (by Kyle Lockwood) in two colour combinations, because they say
different things to different people,” said Professor Burrows.
Professor Burrows advised that the New Zealand Story Group license the use of the New Zealand Fern (a trade mark owned
by New Zealand Way) and have confirmed they would support the use of its fern design depicted on “Silver Fern (Black & White)” by Alofi Kanter, should this alternative flag be chosen by eligible voters in the upcoming referendums.
Architectural designer, Kyle Lockwood, said he had been guided by what New Zealanders had shared throughout the process
in terms of identity and believed that many designers had approached the “brief” similarly.
“New Zealand is a small nation at the bottom of the world and most of us are pretty humble people who don’t like talking
that much about ourselves.
When designing a flag, you have to put all that behind you and say, okay, what will make the world recognise us, what
will make Kiwis proud to carry it and what will bring a tear to your eye when you see it on the podium?” said Mr
Lockwood.
Alofi Kanter, who lives on Auckland’s North Shore with his family and is not a professional designer, said he had a
passionate interest in flags and wanted to take part in the process which had been really interesting and soul
searching.
“I felt it was important that alternative flags referenced where we have come from, acknowledging that the past informs
our present and our future - it is important to find that balance,” said Mr Kanter.
Wellington designer and photographer, Andrew Fyfe, summed up the challenge everyone had faced in visualising a new New
Zealand in the identity their flag designs portray.
“New Zealand has changed a great deal over the last hundred years and will continue to do so. I was thinking not just
about what New Zealand means to me now, but what it means for my kids and what it is going to mean to theirs,” said Mr
Fyfe.
Professor Burrows confirmed that Cabinet has agreed these four designs for inclusion in the first flag referendum. He
reiterated that this was an important time in New Zealand’s history – the very first time Kiwis would have a say in
their flag – and it is important to participate in the referendums.
“This is ‘history in the making’ - these designs offer Kiwis a real choice to consider, think about and rank the flags
in November’s postal referendum. It’s a great opportunity to ‘have a say’ on alternatives, before making a final choice
between the current flag and the preferred alternative in the second referendum next year,” said Professor Burrows.
Mr Burrows thanked everyone who had participated and in particular, the designers of all 10,292 flags that were
submitted as part of the process. More about the four designs, including video interviews with the flag designers, can
be viewed on www.flag.govt.nz.
- ends -
Official four flag alternative designs adopted by Cabinet for inclusion in the first flag referendum
Designer name
Alofi Kanter
Flag design title
Silver Fern (Black & White)
Credit for the fern goes to The New Zealand Way Limited*
About the designer
Alofi Kanter is a 51 year old father of three from Auckland. Originally born in Europe, he lived in Samoa for 10 years
before making New Zealand (and specifically Auckland) his home 20 years ago. His wife works in a rest home and two
daughters are busy studying, with one here at Massey and the other on a student exchange in France. His son works for AJ
Hackett in Queenstown. A flight attendant, he has had no formal art or design training but has a passionate interest in
culture, heritage and flag design.
Designer name
Kyle Lockwood
Flag design title
Silver Fern (Red, White and Blue)
About the designer
Kyle Lockwood is a 38 year old, born and bred in Wellington who inherited a passion for a sport where his father was a
world champion and NZ team coach in underwater hockey. In 1996 he was a limited service volunteer in the NZ Army and
proudly wore the fern on his beret. Despite his Major suggesting a military career, his work at the City Council
Building Department started a passionate career in architecture. Each morning his grandmother raises this flag over her
house.
Designer name
Andrew Fyfe
Flag design title
Koru
About the designer
Andrew Fyfe is a 37 year old, originally born in Thames, who grew up in Tauranga and studied in Auckland before meeting
his wife 17 years ago, cycling 35,000kms around Europe and Asia together and settling in Wellington. A professional
graphic designer and photographer, Andrew has young twins so life is very busy. He first started thinking about our
affinity to our flag when travelling, and especially appreciates New Zealand’s progressiveness as he is the great,
great, great nephew of Kate Sheppard.
Designer name
Kyle Lockwood
Flag design title
Silver Fern (Black, White and Blue)
About the designer
Kyle Lockwood is a 38 year old, born and bred in Wellington who inherited a passion for a sport where his father was a
world champion and NZ team coach in underwater hockey. In 1996 he was a limited service volunteer in the NZ Army and
proudly wore the fern on his beret. Despite his Major suggesting a military career, his work at the City Council
Building Department started a passionate career in architecture, and most recently, sustainable modular architecture.
* The New Zealand Story Group license the use of the New Zealand Fern (a trade mark owned by New Zealand Way) and have
confirmed they would support the use of its fern design depicted on “Silver Fern (Black & White)” by Alofi Kanter, should this alternative flag be chosen by eligible voters in the upcoming referendums.
How New Zealanders have connected with the project
• 10,292 alternative designs published
• 850,000+ online visits
• 6,000+ visits to workshops and information stands
• 1.18m+ people reached by Facebook
• 146,000+ views of the NZ flag history video
• 43,000+ New Zealanders have shared what they stand for (online & via post)
Panel’s selection criteria:
In reviewing flag designs, first and foremost, the Flag Consideration Panel were guided by the results of the ten week
engagement programme across a range of communities where thousands of Kiwis shared what was special about New Zealand.
This provided the Panel, and flag designers, with invaluable direction as to how New Zealanders see themselves and their
country and how those values might best be expressed in a new flag. The Panel agreed a flag should:
• unmistakably be from New Zealand and celebrate us as a progressive, inclusive, environmentally connected country, that
has a sense of its past and a vision of its future;
• be a ‘great’ flag, which means that; it adheres to the principles of good flag design, has an enduring quality which
will not become outdated, and would work well in all situations from celebration to commemoration;
• be inclusive, in that all New Zealanders should be able to see themselves within it; and
• not have any impediments to its use as a potential New Zealand flag.
In making its selection, the Panel invited a number of cultural (including tikanga), vexillology, art and design experts
to provide confidential technical feedback on designs under consideration. The role of these advisors was to review
designs to ensure they are workable and that there are no impediments in the choice of proposed designs.
About the Flag Consideration Project
The Flag Consideration Panel was appointed in February 2015 following nominations by a Cross Party Group of MPs. The
Panel is independent of government and has been provided with a set budget within which it is required to conduct a
public engagement campaign that will culminate in the recommendation of four alternative flag designs to the Responsible
Minister, Hon Bill English.
The Panel is not responsible for the New Zealand Flag Referendums Act 2015 that establishes a process for the holding of
two postal referendums on the New Zealand Flag. Cabinet has specified that the Panel’s public engagement process must be
independent, inclusive, enduring, well-informed, practical, community-driven, dignified, legitimate and consistent with
the Crown’s Treaty obligations.
For more information see: