Ideology And Profits Drive PPPs, Not Economics

Published: Thu 15 Apr 2010 12:20 PM
Ideology And Corporate Profits Drive PPPs, Not Economics
Experience in the UK and Australia shows that Public Private Partnerships are a recipe for profiteering, higher costs to the taxpayer, and loss of control for school principals, said CTU Economist and Policy Director Bill Rosenberg today.
“Even with the levels of the debt that the government carries, which are considerably lower than most other OECD countries, it would be lower cost and a better deal to stay with public provision,” said Rosenberg.
“Examples from the UK are sobering. In January this year the UK’s Independent newspaper analysed 667 schools, hospitals and other public assets in similar ‘Public Finance Initiative’ schemes, and showed that they would pay 262 billion pounds over 30 years for assets with a capital value of 55 billion pounds. Another detailed analysis of six such schemes in 2008 showed that the private interests were earning astronomical returns – 17 to 23 percent rates of return. Three of the projects (hospitals and a college) could have been built for half the cost through normal government borrowing, and ‘huge savings’ could have been made on the other projects, including 11 schools.”
An analysis of PPP roading projects showed the additional cost of PPP projects over public debt was up to 40 percent of the revenues for the roads.
School principals have expressed their frustration at having to wrangle with building owners. They may also lose control of the use of school halls and other potentially money-making facilities. Authorities find themselves left with the bill if numbers of pupils fall or the company pulls out.
“No contract can cover all contingencies,” continued Rosenberg. “Contracts become hugely complex and are a gold mine for lawyers and accountants, both in drawing up the contracts and in finding loopholes for contractors to ask for more.”
“Contrary to the rhetoric, this is a recipe for increasing government debt and communities losing control of their schools and other facilities.”
Council of Trade Unions
Te Kauae Kaimahi
The New Zealand Council of Trade Unions Te Kauae Kaimahi brings together over 350,000 New Zealand union members in 40 affiliated unions. We are the united voice for working people and their families in New Zealand.
Contact NZCTU
Physical Address:
Level 7, West Block, Education House, 178 Willis St, Wellington.
Media Contact:
Postal Address:
PO Box 6645, Marion Square, Wellington 6141.

Next in New Zealand politics

New Zealand Prepared To Send Support To Tonga
By: New Zealand Government
COVID-19 Immunisation Starts For 5 To 11-year-old Tāmariki
By: Ministry of Health
Duke Of York’s NZ Military Patronage Appointment Ends
By: New Zealand Government
Open Letter To Government From Non-bank Lenders: The Path Forward On CCCFA Changes
By: Financial Services Federation
Too Many Kiwi Workers Financially Vulnerable As Omicron Looms - Annual Workforce Survey
Law Changes Locking Out Home Seekers, Urgent Meeting Sought With Government
By: Financial Advice New Zealand
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media