Real Issues No. 283 - University, Transport, Education
Maxim Institute - real issues - No. 283
13 December 2007
Excellence not elitism
A report of two halves
IN THE NEWS
Choosing stability over freedom
EXCELLENCE NOT ELITISM
This week the University of Auckland Council passed a policy which will, from 2009, allow them to restrict the
proportion of undergraduates they admit to courses. Although the reasons for this policy change are largely pragmatic,
it may signal a move away from the ideological drive to push as many people as possible through university and could be
the first step towards a more strategic view of New Zealand's tertiary sector.
The decision was motivated by the University's 2005-2012 strategic plan, which aims to prevent any further increase in
student numbers, instead focusing upon the quality of degrees and their postgraduate programme. The reform of the
government tertiary funding model is another factor that has led to the decision. It will mean that funding will no
longer be based on the number of students enrolled. As a result, the University of Auckland has projected it will lose
around $2 million in 2008 due to the enrolment of 200 unfunded students.
One of the main points of contention over the change has come from the New Zealand Union of Students' Association who
claim it will 'exclude the participation of key under-represented groups within New Zealand's largest city.' The
University has responded with the establishment of a taskforce designed to address such issues through 'affirmative
action' policies. However, dealing with this problem at this stage is missing the point. Access to university should be
related to a student's ability and the fact that students from some ethnic groups are likely to be over-represented in
those missing out highlights an important deficit arising out of the school system. The issue of equity in education
must first be addressed at this level. The focus should be on a high quality of secondary and primary school education
across the board, rather than on using positive discrimination policies, that simply ignore problems lower down the
The decision by the University of Auckland will foster a greater appreciation for university attendance and encourage
those who would go to university on a whim into more productive pathways. Rather than creating an elitist institution,
the new policy represents a step toward fostering the kind of excellence which is often absent in our tertiary
The Land Transport Amendment (No. 4) Bill currently before Parliament would create an offence of driving while under
drugs, using a similar scheme to current drink drive provisions. Submissions on the Bill close tomorrow. The need for
the Bill, which has been sent to the Transport and Industrial Relations Committee for consideration, is backed up by
recent research that shows driving while under the influence of drugs can be just as harmful, if not more so, than
alcohol. The Bill seeks to do two things -- it will restrict access to personal details from the Register of Motor
Vehicles, as well as creating the offence of driving, or attempting to drive, 'while impaired by a drug or drugs.'
If passed, the Bill will set up an offence of drugged driving that attracts the same penalties as drink driving. For a
first or second offence, the maximum penalties would be three months' imprisonment or a fine of $4,500, while for a
third or further offence an offender could receive a maximum of two years' imprisonment or a fine of $6,000. The test
will be whether a police officer has 'good cause' to suspect that a driver has taken a substance, at which point the
individual may be required to undergo a blood test. The Bill offers a defence for prescription drugs, which will
hopefully prevent innocent individuals from unknowingly breaking the law.
A study also released this year backs up the need for the Bill. Research undertaken by the Institute of Environmental
Science and Research Ltd, upon commission of the Police, showed that 'up to 33% of deceased drivers in 2004-2005 had
drugs and alcohol present in their bloodstream.' Further, supporting research was released by the University of Otago in
October, which surprisingly found that 'for young adults there is a greater risk of driving under the influence of
cannabis than alcohol, and the results are more harmful.'
The finer details of this Bill are causing some discussion, but in principle it is supported by all the political
parties. It is an encouraging move, especially when considered in light of this latest research. We should be ensuring
that our roads are not only safe from drunk drivers and the dangers they bring, but drugged drivers also.
A REPORT OF TWO HALVES
A new OECD report contains some encouraging findings about New Zealand pupils' performance. However, it shows that we
must do better for pupils from lower socio-economic backgrounds and that simply spending more is not the answer. The
PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) 2006 study is undertaken triennially and tests the knowledge and
abilities of 400,000 15-year-olds in 57 countries, including all 30 OECD member countries. This year's study focused on
science, whereas the previous two studies focused on mathematics (2003) and reading (2000). New Zealand scored fifth in
science, seventh in reading and eleventh in mathematics, taking a place among the top seven countries overall.
Encouragingly, New Zealand had the highest percentage of pupils reaching the uppermost proficiency level (Level 6), at 4
percent, compared to the OECD average of just 1.3 percent. However, it also had a very high percentage of pupils at
Level 1 or below, at 14 percent. Our least proficient pupils performed more poorly than those in many low-performing
countries. Socio-economic differences accounted for most between-school variations in performance in New Zealand, and
New Zealand was one of the two top-performing countries where socio-economic background played a huge part in the
variation in pupil performance (16 percent).
Although New Zealand scored quite highly in all areas in the study, scores dropped for mathematics and reading since the
2003 study, which is disappointing, especially considering the rise in spending on education in recent years. This
mirrored the findings for most OECD countries, where average primary and secondary education expenditure increased by 39
percent between 1995 and 2004 but average achievement has stayed relatively flat since the first PISA study in 2000.
This demonstrates that simply pouring money into education is not enough; money has to be used wisely to improve
One way this can be done is to give schools greater autonomy to run themselves, as greater autonomy was found to be a
factor in improved performance. Although the study showed that pupils in schools with relatively greater autonomy were
not consistently better performers than those with less autonomy, countries where it was more common to have greater
autonomy performed better than those where it was less common. Improved access to schools for pupils and their families
was also found to be a factor in better performance. Adopting measures like these is important if we are to give all
pupils a decent opportunity to excel, regardless of their socio-economic background.
CHOOSING STABILITY OVER FREEDOM
Would you choose 'freedom of the press' in preference to 'social harmony and peace?' According to a BBC poll only 56
percent of people, from a sample of fourteen countries, would do so. Placing restrictions upon the freedom of the fourth
estate for the sake of 'social harmony' fails to see the important role it plays in keeping the rest of society
accountable and informed. A populous from whom information is withheld is devoid of the power to make change when
necessary. The poll also looks into the performance of 'news organisations' and differences between 'public' and
Read World Divided on Press Freedom
Another stepping stone to the culture heritage of New Zealand has been added with the naming of University of Auckland
professor Michelle Leggott being installed to the office of Poet Laureate for 2007-2008. By recognising an artist, such
as Michelle Leggott, we recognise the value of their art. In doing so we acknowledge the contribution that works of
beauty bring to wider society and the culture in which they exists.
Read some of Michelle Leggott's works on-line at the New Zealand Electronic Poetry Centre
'Upon the education of the people of this country, the fate of this country depends.'
Benjamin Disraeli (1804-1881)
A registered charitable trust, funded by donations, Maxim Institute values your interest and support.
Click here to find out how you can support Maxim Institute http://www.maxim.org.nz/index.cfm/About_us/Support_us
Maxim Institute's regular email publication, Real Issues, provides thought-provoking analysis of developments in policy
and culture in New Zealand and around the world. You can express you views on any of the articles featured in Real
Issues by writing a letter to the editor. A selection of the best letters will be posted each week on Maxim Institute's
Maxim Institute. 49 Cape Horn Road, Hillsborough, Auckland, New Zealand.
Phone: (09) 627 3261, Fax: (09) 627 3264, Email: email@example.com