INDEPENDENT NEWS

Confusing messages about corporal punishment

Published: Thu 12 Oct 2006 11:13 AM
Media information 12 October 2006
Confusing messages about corporal punishment
Beth Wood spokesperson for EPOCH New Zealand (End Physical Punishment of Children) says “Parents and public are understandably confused – on one hand we have an MP drafting potential legislation in 2006 that permits physical discipline and on the other we have the United Nations Secretary General’s study on violence against children recommending that all countries ban corporal punishment of children (including physical discipline in the home)”.
“The future of section 59 Crimes Act hangs in the balance. Full repeal of section 59 would be entirely congruent with the new UN Study’s recommendations, previous recommendations from the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, the New Zealand Action Plan for Human Rights, and positive parenting and family violence prevention initiatives promoted by the Government.
“If we were writing the Crimes Act from start in 2006 would we actually suggest in law that people can hit each other, however mildly, or whatever their age?”
“Much is made of the fear that parents could be prosecuted for minor smacking if section 59 is repealed but is this the real reason there is so much resistance to full repeal or is it that it is hard to put children’s best interests uppermost?
“The primary purpose of repeal is to signal in law the unacceptability of hitting children. Of course it would not be in children’s best interests if parents were prosecuted for minor assault rather than supported to learn new ways of discipline. Ample reassurance already exist. Police have discretion on what they prosecute and there are guidelines in place to help police decide what to prosecute.
Now is the time for leaders to promote children’s interests as a priority?”
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

Fair Pay Agreements To Improve Pay And Conditions For Essential Workers
By: New Zealand Government
Government Sets Pay And Workforce Expectations For The Public Sector
By: New Zealand Government
Budget 2021 Reprioritises Nearly $1 Billion
By: New Zealand Government
Statement On The Speaker And Annual Review Debate
By: New Zealand Government
Mallard Fails To Give Taxpayers A Straight Answer
By: New Zealand National Party
Independent Review To Explore Future For Local Government
By: New Zealand Government
PM Ardern And PM Morrison - Commencement Of Two-way Quarantine-free Travel Between Australia And New Zealand
By: New Zealand Government
Labour Stuck In 1970s With National Awards 2.0
By: New Zealand National Party
ACT Would Repeal Undemocratic Compulsory Unionism
By: ACT New Zealand
Bus Drivers And Supermarket Workers Will Welcome Fair Pay Agreements
By: First Union
E tū Welcomes Next Steps For Fair Pay Agreements
By: E tu
Fair Pay Agreements Should Be Terminated
By: Business NZ
FPAs Have No Place In Modern Workplace - Canterbury Chamber
By: Canterbury Employers' Chamber Of Commerce
No Positive Outcomes From FPA Proposal
By: EMA
Fair Pay Agreements Good News For Employees - Contractors Need Protection Too
By: Public Service Association
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media