Monday 21 February, 2005
Press release # 7
TREAT TERROR THREATS WITH CAUTION
The sources of yesterday’s warning from the Australian Foreign Minister that humanitarian aid workers face an imminent
threat of terrorist attacks need to be analysed and treated with caution, says Caritas Emergencies Officer, Tim
Chiswell, recently returned from Aceh.
“Certainly there are periodic real threats against foreigners in Indonesia and since the tsunami the arrival of groups
such as the Islamic Defenders Front and the Indonesian Mujahadin Council in Aceh has compounded that situation. That is
why agencies such as Caritas have well thought out security procedures in place”, says Mr Chiswell. “But this is also a
complex situation and there are many agendas at work. There are those who have an interest in propagating fear and
promoting a withdrawal of international humanitarian workers from Aceh.”
Prior to the 26th December, civil emergency legislation in Indonesia decreed that Aceh was effectively under military
rule and was off limits to journalists, human rights workers, and most expatriates. While this was relaxed shortly after
the tsunami, barely a fortnight later, the Indonesian vice-President Jusuf Kalla announced that foreign troops should
leave, and this message has been repeated regularly.
“The international presence in Aceh has been very important, not only in the delivery of humanitarian aid, but also in
bolstering the space in which local Aceh organisations and the media have to report on the situation. This is a huge
change from the period of Martial Law and it would be disastrous if unverified threats of potential terrorist attacks
were to undermine that change,” says Mr Chiswell.
“Any heightened concern on security will also likely lead to a strengthened military operation in Aceh. This will
further reduce the prospects of a clear return to civilian government which is the main hope for a peaceful resolution
to the conflict”.
“While Australia is unlikely to reveal the source of its intelligence it is vital that these be investigated thoroughly
and not taken at face value. Even the US government, often a source of intelligence for the Australians, has questioned
whether there is any heightened risk of terror attacks. So has the Indonesian Government”
“During my visit, it was absolutely clear that the Acehnese people very much want international presence to stay, and as
far as possible, we should aim to do that”, says Mr Chiswell.
ENDS