January 6, 2005
CPAG Reject Personal Responsibility
Yesterday, the Child Poverty Action Group rejected "personal responsibility" to advocate for the "principle of
collective responsibility for the children of Aotearoa."
CPAG spokesperson, Dr Nikki Turner described "personal responsibility" as "rhetoric" persisting from the mid-nineties.
Responding to these extraordinary comments Lindsay Mitchell, petitioner for a review of the DPB, said, "The idea of
'personal responsibility' persists because it is sound. There are few social problems that could not be solved if people
accepted individual responsibility for their actions."
"Those children relying on society's 'collective responsibility' for them are the most insecure and vulnerable, for that
very reason. They lack parents prepared to accept and act on their individual responsibility."
"Yet Nikki Turner rejects the Ministry of Social Development's recent statement, "Families/whanau are responsible for
the well-being of their members, particularly that of dependent children" describing it as 'rhetoric'."
For the CPAG the only solution to child poverty must come from the government in the form of 'direct income assistance'.
"What they are advocating is forced state responsibility which undermines individual and family responsibility,"
Mitchell said.
"Turner's co-spokesperson, Dr David Craig, reiterates this saying, 'Without more funding, and more money in the pockets
of the poorest families, it can be a recipe for shifting responsibility down to local levels. If the Minister is serious
here, he won't ask communities to carry the can for what should be central government responsibilities.' "
Mitchell rejects this."The state can never replace the family. Children growing up in safe and caring environments is
about much more than money. It is primarily about personal responsibility and about parents prioritising their
children's needs."
"Historically, New Zealand families have experienced periods of much greater material deprivation than exists today but
by and large they remained intact and functioning. They did not present us with the sad milieu we so often see today."
"The CPAG need to step back and see the bigger picture. Yes, some families need help but that help needs to be on a more
intimate basis. It needs to be help which will lead to independence and control over their own circumstances instead of
ever-growing reliance on the state stumping-up."
Lindsay Mitchell petitioner for a Parliamentary review of the DPB forms available from www.liberalvalues.org.nz contact
dandl.mitchell@clear.net.nz
ENDS