The Campaign against Civil Unions www.civil-unions.org
Media Release No 2 24 November 2004
Anti-Christian bias disqualifies Human Rights Review Tribunal Appointee
The Campaign Against the Civil Union and Relationship Bills has received another nasty communication from Ms Jacquie
Grant a newly appointed member of the Human Rights Tribunal. Spelling and poor grammar aside, we appreciate that she
will have a different view than we have on this proposed legislation, but we were not prepared for the anti-Christian
invective contained in her email message.
Having already accused the Campaign members as “basically cowardly people” who have committed a “hate crime” and that
she intends to take action against us “at every opportunity,” she goes on in her latest communication to demonstrate an
extreme bias against Christians “no matter what denomination / branch of christianity etc … you are all the same.” She
states that those (Christians) whose views on sexuality differ from hers “have rocks in their head” and implies that we
are among this group of rock heads..
Ms Grant has been privileged to have been appointed to a quasi-judicial role on an important Tribunal. Hers is a
statutory appointment. However, there is no way she should remain on the Tribunal. If any Christian group or individual
was the subject of a Tribunal investigation she certainly could not remain on the panel. She has disqualified herself by
exhibiting ill-will, bias and indulging in a level of vitriolic attack that raises serious questions about her whole
appointment and those who appointed her.
Furthermore, she has disqualified herself by lambasting the organisers of a website as indulging in a “hate crime” and
having gone on to make threats against them in her identified role as a Member of the Tribunal. She has breached the
clear boundary of a Tribunal member’s jurisdiction. Her comments cannot be excused as merely personal as she identifies
herself clearly as a member of the Tribunal to which she is accountable and whose reputation she has trashed by her
unethical and inflammatory comments.
The correspondence from Ms Grant is set out below.
Spokesperson Campaign Against Civil Union and Relationship Bills Tel. (06)3444291
Subject: letter for your site if you dare Date: Tue, 23 Nov 2004 11:20:37 + 1300 From: Jacquie Grant “ To: “
I will debate these issues with you anywhere anytime but I think you are basically cowardly people and I do not expect
to have that opportunity soon. Rest assured you will be taken to task at every opportunity for hate crime.
Jacquie Grant MNZM Member Human Rights Commission Review Panel
From: Jacquie Grant
Sent: Wednesday, 24 November 2004 11:07 a.m.
To: Garnet Milne
Subject: Re: re civil unions
I think the Destiny rally says it all about the attitude of the Christian movement and it's intolerance.
I dont [sic] wish to get into a E Mail debate bit [sic] I will leave you with one thought; If as a lot of Christian
people beleive [sic] Homosexuality and the Continium [sic] of sexuality was a matter of choice then can you really
beleive [sic] given the treatement [sic] this group has recieved [sic] from society through the ages anyone would
consiously [sic] make that choice then you have rocks in your head.
If you can accept that there is no choice and in (my case I can tell you I knew from my earliest thoughts I was somehow
different) then you should be supporting us not trying to dsestroy [sic] us and that is what you do. I have known so
many people through my years that have killed themselves because of the pressures from so called christian families it's
no joke, and before you tell me that they are not christians let me tell you no matter what denomination / branch of
christianity etc you are all the same.