Molesworth & Featherston
Business And Political News
7 October 2003
Our ad for us
Reading Molesworth & Featherston for the first time? Browse our back issues at http://www.molesworthandfeatherston.info
(click archives). You can subscribe online.
Molesworth & Featherston is published independently and compiled from informed sources. We aim to publish business and political
information and analysis unavailable in mainstream news media.
You can arrange detailed analysis and exclusive information relevant to your sector. Contact the publishers for a chat: email@example.com
Don't worry, be happy.
After being burned over its outlook for the June quarter, when it picked GDP growth above 0.3 per cent and wore 0.2 per
cent, Treasury is picking a strong rebound in the three months to September.
In its monthly report to finance ministers Treasury was more optimistic about the export outlook and the impact of the
external sector than they had been recently, although the domestic economy (rising house prices, strong retailing,
business and consumer confidence) remained the main driver. External shocks remained the main downside risk. Meat
slaughtering was up 12.8 per cent in July, electricity generation has sparked after the power crisis, and visitor
numbers have remained strong into September. Migrant flows (i.e. long term arrivals) are still strong with arrivals
exceeding departures by 41,000 in the year to August, although the trend is for a slowing from the peak in the first
half of the year.
Treasury spent a lot of time in its latest briefing outlining the trade situation and the current account deficit, which
has surged from 2.6 per cent of GDP a year ago to 4.6 per cent in June and is heading higher. Five per cent is supposed
to be the international alarm level when your currency starts falling out of bed and you face higher and more difficult
credit terms. However we sailed well past six per cent in the mid 1990s and suffered very little so maybe we can do it
Growth among our 14 biggest trading partners has been revised up by 0.2 of a percent in this year and 2004 and now sits
at 2.6 per cent and 3.6 per cent respectively. The IMF's world outlook for 2003 is for 3.2 per cent rising to 4 per cent
Who wants to debate fiscal policy?
We can't understand why there isn't more debate about how the fiscal surpluses - at $5.6 billion for the year to June
2003 - is either spent or handed back in tax cuts.
Maybe no one has an incentive to stimulate a debate on the issue:
- Labour wants to hold off on the issue until it announces its plans in a budget "big bang' close to the 2005 election.
- The National Party doesn't want to get into the issue because it hasn't decided its preferred tax spending mix yet -
and it is still completing policy work.
- The only other party with a sustained interest in fiscal policy is Act, which has predictably argued for the fiscal
surpluses to be returned as tax cuts.
The political problem with holding off debate is that the longer the government waits before spending the surplus, the
more likely it is that the economy will be in a strong upturn. Then increased spending - or tax cuts - would be
pro-cyclical, giving the Reserve Bank the excuse to remove some of the hip-pocket effects by increasing interest rates.
Molesworth & Featherston seeks your suggestions for why more people haven't been thinking up ways to spend the money.
Cabinet this week
Cabinet had a brief agenda on Monday, although it spent time planning for the last 11 week run up to Christmas, which
should see Parliament rise in the week of December 15.
Cabinet's Appointments and Honours Committee met late into the night on Monday putting together the next New Year's
Honours list. Unfortunately, since knighthoods were scrapped, the fun has gone out of honours.
New laws coming your way soon
Between now and Christmas the new Land Transport Management Bill will be dealt with. (It will be accompanied by a review
of major projects under the deal with Greens).
The new dog control law will come out of select committee soon and the Government hopes to pass that before the House
rises for summer.
The Holidays Act revamp will come out of select committee and will be passed by Christmas, making way for the committee
to consider amendments to the Employment Relations Act being drafted now under instruction from Labour Minister Margaret
The Smokefree Bill will be up again next week, no doubt accompanied by more filibustering by Peter Dunne and his party.
New laws for introduction over the next two months include the Electricity Commission legislation (soon), the Maori
Fisheries Allocation law (in November) and the Waitaki River resource consents law.
There is still some work to be done on new rules covering projects of major national significance, which would be fast
tracked through the Resource Management Act and the Environment Court. They are yet to make it to the full Cabinet but
they might still see the light of day before Christmas.
This week in the House
The New Organisms and Other Matters Bill, putting in place arrangements for lifting the GM moratorium - and the
conditions for release -- will continue its committee stages this week, accompanied by a range of protests by the naked
and the semi-dressed.
We see the third reading of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Bill in Judith Tizard's name followed by the
second reading of the Supreme Court Bill and its committee stages on Wednesday - that's the Bill which signals the end
of legal appeals to the Privy Council.
This week outside the House
Today there will be an announcement of a hospitality industry partnership flowing out of Steve Maharey's Jobs Jolt
Wednesday will see the annual report on the student loans scheme tabled, which has what the PM calls "an encouraging
trend'. That is rumoured to show a levelling off in the debt burden for students. Retail trade figures for August will
On Thursday the Auckland mayoral forum will meet PM Clark and other ministers at the Beehive. Also on Thursday research
in the early childhood education area will be released, along with June quarter work stoppages figures.
Party party party.
The party conference season is in full swing. The People's Republic of Christchurch is the venue of choice for NZ First
this weekend, United Future for one day on November 1 (giving them very little time to realise they are on the wrong
side of the political fence in supporting Labour) and the Labour Party will confer there on the weekend starting
The final three
The next chief executive of Radio New Zealand will come from a shortlist of former INL executive Rick Neville, former
political editor Al Morrison, or RNZ's technical operations boss Matt Finn, the only current insider left in the
running. The hot money remains on Neville.
The global economy
After showing signs of recovery - at long last - with six consecutive months of rises, global shares took another slump
Heavyweight credit ratings agency Standard & Poor's points out that the third quarter is historically the weakest for stocks. Despite the solid run, S's global 500 index (of really really big companies) lost 1.2 percent - that's the average loss in Septembers since
1928. S point out that since 1950 the average September loss for its 500-index has been 0.7% -- but it's been a beast for the
last four years averaging losses of 6.4 percent, making this year not so bad by comparison.
For the future, S is tipping global stocks to continue to recover - but quoting Mark Twain: "October: This is one of the peculiarly
dangerous months to speculate in stocks in. The others are July, January, September, April, November, May, March, June,
December, August, and February.'
Crown to buy back railway-station
No jokes about the fat controller. The government is buying Wellington Railway Station from Tranz Rail for $11 million
(including GST and a component which is being described as a payment to Tranz Rail to move out while renovations take
place). Another $14.5 million is being paid for upgrades and maintenance, $25 million all together.
The funds will come from money set aside when the government announced earlier this year its purchase of trace
More seats in the Singapore sky
Even more competition is on the way for would-be alliance partners Air New Zealand and Qantas. Singapore Airlines is
adding extra flights and introducing larger aircraft on New Zealand and Australian routes.
Singapore Airlines is recovering from its first ever loss this year, suffered when the SARs virus wiped out Asian
tourism. If they can make the route pay.
In other email
- Molesworth & Featherston occasionally reviews content in other email newsletters.
It's sometimes said that an economist who makes predictions is an economist who is preparing an explanation for why the
facts don't fit the model.
Leading economic consultancy NZIER bravely publishes quarterly predictions.
In September 2002 (halfway through the previous financial year) it forecast GDP growth for 2002-03 of 2.9 percent. In
fact, for the year ended June 2003, the economy grew 4.0 percent.
NZIER's analysis: "In coming quarters, the impact of falling export revenue will be felt on domestic demand. Employment
growth will ease and wages will grow more slowly. However, softness in consumption growth will largely be offset by a
lift in the value of exports as global growth accelerates. The strength in the Australian housing market will boost
manufactured exports, and tourism will pick up as incomes increase overseas."
The astrological echoes challenge your reviewer. Was NZIER forecasting "falling export revenue' or "a lift in the value
of exports' along with a "boost [in] manufactured exports'?
What actually happened? Falling export revenue did soften domestic demand, but a robust domestic economy (entirely
missed by the forecast) meant employment growth remained strong (unemployment continued to fall) and real wages
continued to grow. Tourism suffered an unexpected blow from SARs (which could not have been predicted) but displayed
This September, NZIER is forecasting "growth will moderate to 2.2% and 2.0% in the years to March 2004 and March 2005
Quote of the week
"The PM is being a very cheeky Clarky."
- Ngai Tahu's Tahu Potiki discussing the foreshore and seabed issue at an Act Party seminar, as quoted by Act "The
Molesworth & Featherston welcomes your feedback. Email us at: firstname.lastname@example.org
Molesworth & Featherston is published on Tuesdays to be New Zealand's most up-to-date business and political newsletter.
You are encouraged to forward this copy. Copyright remains with the publishers.