Personal Grievance Rights Must be Restored
The Council of Trade Unions is calling for the restoration of personal grievance rights after the release of a report
showing a pro-employer trend in decisions in the Court of Appeal.
The independent report by Professor Gordon Anderson of the Victoria University Faculty of Law, which was commissioned by
the CTU, was released today.
The Anderson Report traces the erosion of an objective approach in a number of Court of Appeal decisions to the
increasingly subjective employer-based standard which limits the ability of the Court to review an employer decision.
“It seems that some rather basic principles of fairness have gone out of the window in our highest appeal court,” CTU
president Ross Wilson said.
“It is unthinkable that the Court would be responding to the sustained employer campaign on employment law, but it is
difficult not to see a coincidence of events.”
To rub salt into the workers’ wound the Court of Appeal has also suppressed compensation awards to workers who get past
the new restrictive tests for challenging their dismissal.
Evidence in support of this view is provided in the 20 Employment Tribunal and Authority cases reviewed recently in a
substantial paper to the Employment Law Institute by Chief Judge Goddard which he concluded revealed ‘a pattern of
extremely low awards’.
“It is 30 years since personal grievance rights were introduced to replace strike action by fellow workers of the
grievant,” said Ross Wilson.
“A job is of economic, social, and personal importance to individual workers. The law should be fair and the remedies
realistic. The Report confirms the law is neither.”
The Anderson Report can be found on the CTU website www.union.org.nz.