“Health Minister Annette King should take a cold shower after her personal attack on the chairperson of the NZ Medical
Association Dr Pippa Mackay this morning over the withdrawal of GPs from maternity care,” said Mr Ian Powell, Executive
Director of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, today.
Mr Powell was referring to the acrimonious debate on Morning Report (Radio New Zealand) between the Minister and Dr
Mackay. Dr Mackay is also a member of the ASMS.
“Regrettably Annette King resorted to the disreputable tactic of attacking the messenger instead of simply debating the
message. This has been a tactic of some former health ministers and we had hoped that she was above this.”
“It appears to be part of a deliberate strategy to isolate the NZMA and Dr Mackay because it does not like what it says.
It indicates a political siege mentality. This is a foolish strategy that will fail and ultimately prove
counter-productive. Do not the Minister’s advisers understand history?”
“She is either living in cloud 9 or engaging in political spin if it thinks that Dr Mackay and the NZMA are out on a
limb. Their professional assessment is consistent with other specialised medical organisations with experience in this
field including our members.”
“The issue is whether GPs withdrawing from obstetrics is a bad thing or not. The Minister obviously believes that it
does not matter and no one should be concerned. It is her right to hold this view providing that she understands that
the medical profession strongly believes that she is fundamentally wrong.”
“Annette King’s attack this morning risks creating a major rift between her and the medical profession that will be
difficult to overcome. Some quiet wise reflection on the implications of this would not go astray,” concluded Mr Powell.
Ian Powell
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
For further information please contact:
04 499.1271 work 021 445.521 cellphone 04 292.8214 home