INDEPENDENT NEWS

Tax debate needs an audit

Published: Sun 25 Jul 1999 06:44 PM
Sunday 25th Jul 1999
Richard Prebble
Both National and Labour are using shonky figures in the tax debate, according to ACT Leader and former Associate Finance Minister Richard Prebble.
"Bill English and Michael Cullen are both making up figures for their tax and social spending promises," Mr Prebble said. "Neither MP wants to blow the whistle on the other because it would show that their claim is also absurd.
"Let me show how false the campaign promises are. A 1% tax cut would cost no more than $300 million, and not the $400 million claimed by Bill English - answers given by the Treasury show he is 25% out.
"His claim for a matching $400 million in social expenditure is even more ludicrous. The only explanation for the figure can be that it's $50 million more than Labour's and he believes it shows National cares. Just in this year's budget there is allowance for $600 million more spending, yet he is claiming only $400 million over 3 years. In the last 6 years on average National has increased social spending by $100 million a year. So $400 million in 3 years would represent a massive cut.
"Labour doesn't point this out because to do so would be to demonstrate that their claim that they can finance increased social spending from the at maximum $330 million extra from 1% tax increase is absurd. Labour's ACC promises alone are conservatively estimated to cost $1 billion. Labour last election themselves estimated that the cost of their extra social spending would be $3 billion, and that doesn't include the ACC promise.
"National's promise to match tax cuts with social spending is also not connected to reality. If National had matched tax cuts to social spending over the last 6 years, we would now have a flat tax rate of 17 cents in the dollar.
"National and Labour both need ACT to keep them honest," Mr Prebble said.
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

On National Being Shafted By Its Own Creation
By: Gordon Campbell
Green Party: 'Fruitful discussions ... further discussions to have'
By: RNZ
No changes to border exemptions after fishing crew test Covid-19 positive
By: RNZ
Labour-led Government Has Mandate For Transformation, Equality And Transparency
By: Public Service Association
New Report Shows Significant Changes To New Zealand’s Climate
By: Statistics New Zealand
Judith Collins: Obese people must take responsibility for 'personal choices'
By: RNZ
Poll Reveals Tamihere On Cusp Of Historic Māori Movement Election Victory
By: The Maori Party
On Four-year Terms Of Parliament, And On How The US Courts Are Dismantling Democracy
By: Gordon Campbell
The NZ election saw record vote volatility — what does that mean for the next Labour government?
By: The Conversation
Election Night Results For The 2020 General Election
By: Electoral Commission
On Why The Greens Shouldn’t Join The Government
By: Gordon Campbell
A Government For All NZ Must Be Diverse - Greens Co-Leader
By: RNZ
Government Will Be Formed 'Within The Next Two To Three Weeks' - Jacinda Ardern
By: RNZ
Election Delivers High Expectations For Working People
By: E tu
Businesses Need Predictability And Acceleration
By: Canterbury Employers Chamber of Commerce
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media