INDEPENDENT NEWS

No Need for Knee-Jerk Bank Bashing in New Zealand

Published: Wed 19 Sep 2018 12:47 PM
Submitters to the Finance and Expenditure Committee showed that New Zealand can afford to spare itself a round of bank bashing.
“Consumer New Zealand presented pitiful evidence," says ACT Leader David Seymour. “They showed a few people they knew of anecdotally had been sold insurance they didn’t need and, with some exacerbation, revealed the predictable news that banks try to upsell their customers extra products.”
Under questioning, Consumer New Zealand could not say how banks operating in New Zealand compared with those operating in Australia. When asked, ‘on a scale of 1-10, 10 being bad and representing the behaviour of Australian banks, where would you rate New Zealand banks?’ Consumer New Zealand said ‘that’s a hard question for us to answer.’
The Banking Ombudsman, ‘claiming to be the canary in the coal mine,’ submitted that the New Zealand banking system is functioning well compared with Australia’s. Significantly, they said the systematic abuses found in Australia do not exist here. They went on to agree it would be implausible that the Banking Ombudsman would not be aware of what’s happening in the sector, given the level of engagement they have with bank customers.
“There is a real danger to exaggerating problems in any industry, and the danger is knee-jerk regulation that leaves industries hog tied in red tape,” says Mr Seymour.
“The financial sector is already regulated by the Commerce Commission, the Reserve Bank, and the Financial Markets Authority.
“Already, practitioners complain of burdensome red tape and regulation. The worst thing that could happen is further regulation of the sector, adding costs to solve no problem.
“It is important to recognise that just because something happens in Australia, does not mean it happens here. In cricket, Australians bowl underarm and tamper with the ball but New Zealanders play fair. It may just be that the problem with banking in Australia is cultural, not systematic.”

Next in New Zealand politics

ACT: Regulatory Constitution will improve quality of law
By: ACT New Zealand
Revised offer for teachers and principals
By: New Zealand Government
National supporting primary sector growth
By: New Zealand National Party
On the war purposes of our massive defence spend-up
By: Gordon Campbell
Government supports collective bargaining for film and screen
By: New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
WTF? There’s a giant oil rig on the horizon
By: Greenpeace
Tova O'Brien interviews Act Party leader David Seymour
By: Newshub Nation
New bill will protect freedom of expression
By: ACT New Zealand
ACT launches Freedom to Earn tax plan
By: ACT New Zealand
ACT announces Freedom to Learn education policy
By: ACT New Zealand
National Maori Authority Chair slams David Seymour
By: Maori Council
Proposed 17.5% flat tax would cause economic boom
By: ACT New Zealand
A new offer on the table for secondary teachers
By: PPTA
Primary teachers to vote on a proposed settlement
By: NZEI
National welcomes new offer for teachers
By: New Zealand National Party
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media