INDEPENDENT NEWS

ACT Opposes Provocation Repeal Bill

Published: Thu 26 Nov 2009 09:35 AM
ACT Opposes Provocation Repeal Bill
David Garrett MP, ACT New Zealand
Wednesday, November 25 2009
ACT New Zealand Justice Spokesman David Garrett today reiterated ACT's opposition to the Crimes (Provocation Repeal) Amendment Bill until such time as alternative defences – such as diminished responsibility – are put into law.
"This would ensure that mitigating circumstances are taken into account when individuals are on trial, as advocated by the New Zealand Law Society and senior prosecutors," Mr Garrett said.
"If successful, the partial defence of provocation reduces 'charged with murder' to 'guilty of manslaughter'. This defence is open to both men and women and – contrary to recent claims – victim's sexual orientation is irrelevant. It is not – and never has been – a 'gay panic' defence.
"This defence was recently highlighted when Clayton Weatherston attempted to use provocation as a defence, but failed. This failure shows that the defence is working, and still has a place in the 21st century.
"Had provocation as a defence been repealed, however, Weatherston could have raised it at sentencing - causing exactly the same distress to Sophie Elliot's family as he did in the trial itself. Arguably it would have been worse, as the Elliot family would have had to undergo two separate ordeals at Weatherston's hands.
"Arguments for a repeal of the defence are weak, at best. It should be a jury of one's peers – not a judge – that decides whether the defence is justified," Mr Garrett said.
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

Global Military Spending Increase Threatens Humanity And The Planet
By: Peace Movement Aotearoa
Government To Introduce Revised Three Strikes Law
By: New Zealand Government
Environmental Protection Vital, Not ‘Onerous’
By: New Zealand Labour Party
Elevated Levels Of Nitrate Contamination Found In Canterbury Drinking Water
By: Greenpeace
Trade Relationship With China Remains Strong
By: New Zealand Government
Maori Authority Warns Government On Fast Track Legislation
By: National Maori Authority
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILE © Scoop Media