INDEPENDENT NEWS

Political Prostate Inquiry is Daft and Dangerous

Published: Thu 18 Jun 2009 10:01 AM
18 June 2009
Political Prostate Inquiry is Daft and Dangerous
The Health Select Committee’s prostate cancer inquiry, announced today, is potentially dangerous political interference and a waste of the Committee’s time said Green Party MP Kevin Hague, who is a member of the Committee.
“When politicians start making complex medical decisions it’s dangerous and a recipe for disaster,” said Kevin Hague, Green Party Health and Wellbeing spokesperson.
“The Government seems hell-bent on having this inquiry, and has chosen to do so before even the finalising terms of reference. This suggests an intent to reach conclusions based on what will be popular, rather than based on evidence. This is not the best way to develop health policy.
“The Ministry of Health has already commissioned a new literature review of prostate cancer screening, which will be available in November, and it seems completely daft for the Select Committee to effectively duplicate this expert review.
“This is a hotly debated issue which requires perspectives from different expert groups, including specialist disciplines of cancer screening programmes, epidemiology, urology, pathology, oncology, general practice, and health economics, as well as men’s perspectives.
“Balancing these perspectives requires clinical judgment and skill, and is not an appropriate function for the Select Committee, which after all is a political forum.”
Note: Kevin Hague has had a long term interest in men’s health issues and the prevention of prostate cancer. He previously chaired the NZ Public Health Advisory Committee, and represented all DHBs on the National Screening Advisory Committee.
For more information:
National Health Committee report on prostate cancer from 2004 - http://www.nhc.health.govt.nz/moh.nsf/indexcm/nhc-prostate-cancer-screening?Open
Population Screening for Prostate Cancer - A Systematic Review
http://www.nzgg.org.nz/guidelines/0041/Population_Screening_for_Prostate_Cancer___A_systematic_review.pdf
ENDS

Next in New Zealand politics

Gordon Campbell on the farming sector’s persecution complex
By: Gordon Campbell
Independent review of prisoner mail management released
By: Department Of Corrections
IPCA releases reports on the unlawful detention of teenager
By: Independent Police Conduct Authority
New safety measures for modified pistols
By: New Zealand Government
Government fixes culturally arranged marriage visa issue
By: New Zealand Government
Budget investigation shut down and new inquirer appointed
By: State Services Commission
Mysterious foundation loaning New Zealand First money
By: RNZ
Criminal Cases Review Commission established
By: New Zealand Government
National backs farmers marching against Govt policies
By: New Zealand National Party
Ag Proud NZ encourage positive not provocative actions
By: Ag Proud
March on Parliament deliberately created confusion
By: NZ Forest Owners' Association
Who will pick up Essential Freshwater’s $80b price tag?
By: DairyNZ
DairyNZ claim of economic ruin "misleading"
By: Fish and Game New Zealand
New Zealand Roundtable for Sustainable Beef launched
By: Beef And Lamb NZ
Personality important in farmer anxiety
By: Lincoln University
View as: DESKTOP | MOBILEWe're in BETA! Send Feedback © Scoop Media