Hon Chris Carter
Spokesperson for Education
12 December 2008Media Statement
Labour rejects exams for 5 year olds.
Labour will vote against the Education (National Standards) Amendment Bill when it is introduced into the House later
this evening.
“We cannot support this legislation because of its content and because the process the National government is using to
ram through the legislation in urgency,” said Labour’s Education spokesperson Chris Carter.
“National testing is enormously controversial, both in NZ and internationally. The process of ramming this bill through
without any chance for parents, teachers, the School Trustees Associations and educational experts to comment on
legislation is wrong.
“The bill requires state schools to assess and report student performance against national standards. This will
inevitably lead to the establishment of league tables of “winner” and “loser” schools and compound the challenges lower
decile schools already face in attracting students and staff.
“Standardised testing has been disastrous in the US and the UK. Teachers have been forced to teach to exam scripts
rather than focus on each child’s literacy and numeracy development. Enormous stress has been placed on very young
children to pass the test.
“One Kiwi in four was born outside New Zealand and some 22% of New Zealand pupils come from homes where English is a
second language. Such pupils will face barriers in any comparative age related literacy assessment
“Labour intends to move amendments to the legislation which will seek to ensure that league tables cannot used by the
National-led government to penalise schools.
“Labour will also move to include provisions in the legislation that will ensure parents can have confidence that their
own children’s test results will remain private. We can only help the Government will start listening,” said Chris
Carter.
ENDS