Hon Dr Michael Cullen
Labour Party Deputy Leader
13 October 2008
Nats do not know the cost of their own policies
Finance Minister Michael Cullen was today surprised to learn that the man who is vying for his job doesn't even know the
fiscal impact of his own party's tax policy.
Mr English, during a Radio New Zealand debate on tax policy, said that the National Party's tax package would deliver an
injection into the New Zealand economy of $7 to $8 billion next year,"Dr Cullen said.
Mr English said that this was money that "at the moment [New Zealand] is not going to get.
"Mr English is trying to tell us that National's tax plan will deliver an extra $7 to $8 billion on 1 April next year
into the New Zealand economy.
"This is absurd and I was very surprised to hear this announcement.
"They previously said that the impact of their tax cuts was $3.7 billion over 3 Â¼ years," Dr Cullen said. "And that is
before they remove the injection of $900 million for R tax credits from 2009.
When questioned by the Finance Minister live on-air, Mr English seemed to back track saying he wasn't sure about the
numbers and would have to check.
These latest comments from Mr English follow on from his comments to the New Zealand Herald on Saturday which indicated
that the current publicly available National policy on KiwiSaver could be changed if National actually forms the next
"I would urge Mr English to make himself clear - was this a slip of the tongue or does the National Party have deeper
tax cutting plans that they are yet to tell the voters of New Zealand about?" Dr Cullen asked.