Phil Heatley MP
National Party Fisheries Spokesman
08 January 2008
Fisheries bureaucrats up, prosecutions down
The number of bureaucrats sitting behind desks at the Ministry of Fisheries in Wellington is growing while the number of
people being nabbed for poaching is down, says National's Fisheries spokesman, Phil Heatley.
"Latest figures show that the number of defendants facing fisheries offences has dropped by 35% from 370 in 2002 to 239
in 2007.
"In addition, the number of infringement notices that have been issued has plummeted 43% from 2,265 to 1,490 over the
same period.
"It is no co-incidence that these figures follow a steady decline in the number of Honorary Fisheries Officers under
Labour. Beach patrols have dropped with the gutting of this service by 30% from 246 officers in 2002 to 170 in 2007.
"All the while the number of full-time fisheries officers trying to do the volunteers' essential front-line work has
only increased by 23, yet the Ministry's office-bound bureaucracy has risen by almost 40%.
"While the bureaucracy is getting fatter in Wellington, the front-line force on our beaches is being stretched to the
point where fewer poachers are being held to account.
"This Government claimed as part of its 'Poaching Is Theft' campaign, that 'everyone has a part to play in ensuring the
sustainability of New Zealand's valuable fisheries'.
"So what part has Labour played? Instead of taking a leadership approach, it has in fact reduced the number of eyes and
ears on the ground, and has created more opportunities for people to plunder our coastline."
Ends
Figures attached
--
Question: How many infringement notices were issued by the Ministry in each of the 2002/03, 2003/04, 2004/05, 2005/06
and 2006/07 financial years and how many of these notices were either paid or successfully defended for each of these
years?
Portfolio: Fisheries
Minister: Hon Jim Anderton
Date Lodged:16/11/2007
Answer Text: Please refer to the following table:
Year Infringement Infringement Successfully
notices issued notices paid defended
by year end
2002/03 2,265 911 01
2003/04 2,105 1,003 nil
2004/05 1,757 825 01
2005/06 1,453 525 01
2006/07 1,490 645 01
The balance of infringement notices issued were withdrawn, waived, hearing requested or referred to the Department of
Courts for collection.
Attachment: None
Date Received:06/12/2007
--
Question: How many prosecutions were undertaken by the Ministry in each of the 2002/03, 2003/04, 2004/05, 2005/06 and
2006/07 financial years (excluding the number of infringement notices issued, paid or defended for each year) and how
many of these prosecutions resulted in convictions being entered or charges found proven by the court for each of these
years?
Portfolio: Fisheries
Minister: Hon Jim Anderton
Date Lodged:16/11/2007
Answer Text: Please refer to the following table showing the number of Fisheries Act prosecutions undertaken by the
Ministry's Compliance Prosecution team:
Year No of No of Defendants still Plea arrangement,
defendants defendants before the Court withdrawn or
convicted as at 30 June dismissed
2002/03 370 177 147 46
2003/04 328 185 132 11
2004/05 288 160 97 31
2005/06 210 115 79 16
2006/07 239 134 98 7
Attachment: None
Date Received:28/11/2007
--